Friends & Fellow Citizens
In this unique civics podcast, discover how the principles of George Washington's Farewell Address (patriotism, civility, faith, education, national unity, and fiscal responsibility) apply to today! With a focus on American political institutions and policymaking, hear fascinating stories and discussions that any America-loving listener can enjoy!
This non-partisan podcast is a remarkable mix of solo shows, interviews and special guests that gives you a great boost of freedom! New episodes on the first two Mondays of each month!
Friends & Fellow Citizens
#215: Columbus Day Bonus Ep. - Self-made Speaker: How Clay Molded Congress feat. Dr. Jacob Wood
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The famous, unresolved question "Who discovered America?" is still one that we Americans still ask ourselves.
But when we think of explorers, we should also think of those who explored and shaped our institutions. One of our most notable "explorers" is Henry Clay.
Dr. Jacob Wood, Editorial Specialist at the Kentucky Historical Society, discusses the significance and impact of one of America's most notable political leaders. We even delve into the connection between Clay and Lincoln!
Check out the Kentucky Historical Society website and make a visit to the state capital of Frankfort!
Visit georgewashingtoninstitute.org to sign up for our e-mail list! The site is the one-stop shop of all things Friends & Fellow Citizens and George Washington Institute!
JOIN as a Patreon supporter and receive a FREE Friends & Fellow Citizens mug at the $25 membership level!
IMPORTANT NOTE/DISCLAIMER: All views expressed by the host are presented in his personal capacity and do not officially represent the views of any affiliated organizations. All views presented by guests are solely those of the interviewees themselves and may or may not represent the views of their affiliated organizations, the host, Friends & Fellow Citizens, and/or The George Washington Institute.
But by the time Clay was elected to the House of Representatives in his own right, he had enough authority, he had enough uh respect that he was na he was elected Speaker of the House on his very first day in the House, which is is wild. Yeah, you would not see that in the House of Representatives today. No, you need like 10, 20 years of experience in the House. Uh, but no, Clay got it on his first day.
SPEAKER_00Patriotism, faith, national unity, education, physical responsibility, civility, the values that define America. Fascinating stories and talks from America-loving patriots dedicated to preserving freedom, opportunity, and justice. Welcome to the Friends and Fellows Citizens Podcast. Hello, everybody. Welcome to the Friends and Fellow Citizens Podcast. I'm your host, German Talowski. Thank you all so much for joining me for this interview episode. This is a bonus episode that we are having on Columbus Day. And so we are looking forward to having another guest join us for this unique episode. So if you are new to this podcast, I want to first welcome you aboard. Welcome to our show. I hope you will enjoy our many, many other episodes that are coming up, but also many that we have already done. And I hope you will find a topic that interests you. And there's just so much that we're looking forward to. And so thank you for joining us. As always, I'll have to first acknowledge and thank our Patreon supporters. I really appreciate what they do to help me keep this show going. So if you are interested in becoming a part of this podcast, a podcast that values talking about institutions, about connecting with Washington's farewell address, with the principles of our country, please, please consider become part of our Patreon page and part of our Patreon community. And you also enjoy cool benefits as well. All the levels are down in the show notes below. Uh, we'll start having uh more uh not just episodes but in general, but more video episodes that are coming out. So uh let's aim for that. And if you have already make sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel, uh if you are a big YouTube person, and obviously we are on podcast apps as well, so be sure to check those out. Uh, make sure to subscribe so you get notifications when new episodes come out. Now, as this podcast episode is being released on Columbus Day, I was thinking to myself, other than just thinking about history, uh, because obviously that's what we think of with regards to Columbus. Of course, Columbus never met Washington and it was way too early to uh show up to this part of the world. However, I was thinking to myself, explore. Like what does it mean to explore something? And I'm thinking, since this podcast does talk a lot about institutions, what is the best way, or what are ways we can think about exploring an institution? And there's a figure whom I mentioned before, and other guests have mentioned as well, but we've never really delved straight into this figure. Probably one of the most well-known figures uh when we think about Congress, and that person is Henry Clay. And so this episode is about one of the most famous members of Congress in our nation's history, and is also really fitting because last year I had the opportunity to drive through Kentucky uh on the way to Alabama, and I was able to visit for the very first time, Frankfurt, Kentucky, which is the state capitol, and got to meet some really wonderful people. And I am very delighted that we have one of the scholars from the Kentucky Historical Society joining us for this episode. So without further ado, let's get right into our episode with our guest. All right, everybody. I'm very excited to welcome from the Kentucky Historical Society and Dr. Jacob Wood. Jacob, thank you so much for coming to our podcast today.
SPEAKER_02Oh, it's so great being here. I'm really excited when when I saw that you were interested in talking about this. So thank you for having me.
SPEAKER_00No problem. I want to first give a shout out to Mackenzie. Uh, she is absolutely amazing and funny story. But I was going to see a friend in Louisville, and I thought, well, Frankfurt's not that far. So I figured I'd do the drive. And I was blown away by, first of all, just how cute that town is. Frankfurt. A really, really amazing little place. And went to the old state capitol. There's two capitals there. There's the old one, and of course, the new one that that's uh actually currently in renovation, to my understanding. Mackenzie was one of the tour guides, and she gave a phenomenal tour. And uh, and and it's not easy to do that in August uh either in Kentucky. So I just appreciate that. I kept in touch with her. Uh, we've kept in touch ever since, and she was very kind enough to connect to you and me. And I just appreciate what uh an organization like KHS does to inform not just Kentuckians, but really all visitors to the state and to learn about the history. And before we get on our main topic, Jacob, can you just share a bit about yourself, introduce yourself to our audience?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh I'm Jacob Wood. Uh I work as an editorial specialist with the Civil War Governors of Kentucky Digital Documentary Edition here at the Kentucky Historical Society. And I graduated in 2023 with my PhD in American history. And I've been working here at KHS for the past, oh gosh, since February of last year. So I'm really grateful to be here. The team here is fantastic. And you know, we're able to do a lot of really great work at spreading Kentucky history to whether people of Kentucky or nationally through mediums like your like your podcast.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, including including Nevada's just wandering around in the exactly. Uh I appreciate that. And now I want to uh go a bit more specific into your research interests. Why specifically the 19th century uh of American politics for you?
SPEAKER_02So I'm gonna let you in on a little secret. Uh at first, I was actually planning on majoring and focusing on ancient Greek and ancient Roman history. But in 10th grade uh APUS history, I'm going through the textbook and all of a sudden you start seeing this guy pop up. And you hear about all these compromises that he made, you hear about all these times he ran for president. And so 16-year-old me is like, oh, this guy's kind of neat. I want to learn more about him. Then eventually, as you're learning more about him, you're like, oh, this time period is really interesting. So uh you know, 16-year-old me was all in on ancient Greece and ancient Rome. By the time I'm 19 and in college, I'm going, you know what? 19th century US history, 19th century US political history is really where my heart's at. And so I've been a student of that ever since.
SPEAKER_00Wow. I just love how people really discover their passions and interests without them actually actively looking for those interests. I always say that curiosity comes to us more than we find curiosity, in the sense that things really do come when you have that open mind and you're just sifting through a book and you see and you read something about somebody that you're like, oh my gosh, where do you come from? You know, like kind of pops out of nowhere. Can you share with us more about the mission, the vision, and what you all do at KHS?
SPEAKER_02Certainly. Uh the mission at the Kentucky Historical Society is to educate and engage people through Kentucky's history to meet the challenges of the future. Uh, we we are a leader in helping people understand and share Kentucky's stories. And we do this by valuing that culture of discovery that you you just mentioned, that sort of mindset of discovery that inspires and motivates learners of all ages. The work at KHS, we we really place a high level of authenticity, research, fact. After all, we serve the public. And so our goal is to serve the public with the best information we can.
SPEAKER_00Wow. And uh and I I imagine that there's probably a lot of visitors asking for asking you for some free Kentucky bourbon, right?
SPEAKER_02Uh I don't give that out for free. That's that stuff stays locked away at my house. The good stuff at least.
SPEAKER_00Uh that's awesome. And luckily there's four knocks if you if you guys have some extra extra bourbon to store. Uh all right. I want to Jacob, I want to get to our main topic, and that's about Clay. And I think Clay is such an interesting figure, in part because of the time he was born, because he was born in 1777, the year after the Declaration of Independence was uh assigned. And growing up alongside the early years of the country, uh particularly when you don't have a recollection of what happened in before, that seems kind of an interesting time to get yourself involved in politics. So, what can you share about Clay's early involvement or early life and how he got interested in politics when he was a young man?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Uh so Clay he grows up in a neighborhood of near Richmond called the Slashes in Hanover County. And yeah, Clay and his supporters later later in his life sort of create a mythology of him as this kind of working class hero. They call him the millboy of the slashes. There's little pictures of him on the back of a horse with giant flower sacks, you know, really presenting that kind of frontier uh common man log cabin lifestyle. The truth is that he had a he was had a few more resources than I think him and his allies gave him credit for. Uh when his father passed away, he inherited two enslaved people. So already at four years old, he has I hate to say it, you know, he has property. And when his mother remarries, his stepfather was able to connect him with leading lawyers and political figures in Richmond. You know, here you have this teenager, 14, 15, 16 years old, who now has access to the mind of George Witt, the signer of the Declaration of Independence. And he's sort of a legal apprentice for him for a time. But what really starts Clay's political career is as he makes it to Kentucky at the end of the 1790s, Kentucky is a brand new state. And during this period, you see the formation of political parties in the United States. You see John Adams, Alexander Hamilton with the Federalists, Thomas Jefferson and James Madison with they would have called themselves the Republicans, but you know, the historians call them the Democratic Republicans to separate. And Clay was really drawn to Jefferson and Madison, the Democratic Republicans. Some of his earliest public writings are against things like the Alien and Sedition Act. Yeah, he he sees himself as this kind of freedom fighter, this much more of a radical figure. He he wants the state of Kentucky to have a new state constitution where there's more elected offices, where there's a gradual emancipation of slavery. He's really kind of a firebrand in this regard.
SPEAKER_00Wow. A lot of people might not realize is that the volatility of the political parties was really crazy in their early years. I want to also step back and say that there's so much to talk about with Henry Clay. And so the goal here, really, of this conversation is to see why Henry Clay is important for shaping American politics in the 19th century and how those implications would play out within our institutions. Jacob, I want to go to uh a bit more bit more about Clay himself in terms of how he he gets associated with the politics of what we now know as the Whig Party and kind of how he he helped envision that. Can you just talk a little bit about uh what the Whig Party was and how Clay fits into that?
SPEAKER_02So Clay was one of the instrumental founders of the Whig Party. The election of 1824, you have Jackson and his supporters basically rallying around Jackson himself, and you see this really stark division between Jackson's supporters and this sort of loose coalition of opponents of Jackson. They try and run a few election cycles and it doesn't work. Uh John Quincy Adams runs for re-election against Jackson, trounced. So when Jackson became president, his coalition, his coalition rather, learned very quickly that governing is a lot different than running for political office. So you had all these western supporters of Jackson, you had all these southern supporters of Jackson, these northern supporters of Jackson who they helped bring him to office. There's Jacksonian majorities in Congress. Well, Jackson starts making decisions, administration starts making policy, and this starts turning people off. And I don't know how much detail you want me to go, but things like the Indian Removal Act, things like uh vetoing the national bank in 1832, his removal of the deposits from the National Bank later on in the 1830s, then especially Jackson's response to South Carolina nullifying or attempting to nullify the tariff of 1828. It turns off several of his supporters and they start mixing in with this loose coalition, and by the middle of the 1830s, they create this name for themselves. They call themselves the Whigs. But Clay wanted the Whig Party to be more than just opposition to Andrew Jackson. He wanted the party to mean something deeper, bigger. And that is gonna be what becomes known as the American system. He started uh arguing about it, or arguing for it in the 1820s, but really by the 1830s, 1840s, the American system becomes solidified uh as its three main planks are first, a national bank to regulate national credit, house government finances, and ensure that basically the American economy was stable. Secondly, federally funded internal improvements designed things like ferries, canals, bridges, roads, turnpikes, all of these infrastructure projects that not only would tie Americans together economically, but hopefully socially, culturally, emotionally. And then there was a high protective tariff that was designed to artificially inflate foreign goods coming into the country. So that way, by comparison, American goods seem cheaper, and it will help some of the factories and companies that are coming out of New England specifically. So Clay really wants this to be the bedrock of the Whig Party, and it becomes the bedrock of his belief as to some of the things government should be doing.
SPEAKER_00Well, what you said there about how Clay wanted it more than just opposition to Jackson. Imagine if our political parties listen to that, I just think as a remarkable, however people stand on politics, it really is important to stand for something, isn't it? Like important to have a policy platform and in response to what people are concerned about. And that's part of democracy, right? Is to try and find solutions to answering these questions or resolving these issues, not just saying, Well, that I just don't like that. Did Clay understand the the opportunities to uh capture that that sour mood that people had about politics? Do you think Jackson's rise was uh perhaps a lot bigger than he maybe he had anticipated as he's trying to catch up with a party that is still new, but the fact that he Jackson did have those very staunch supporters of his?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh I think not just Clay, but I think there are many in the political establishment. Clay, John Quincy Adams, who are really sort of taken aback that Jackson became so popular. And so Clay looking back on it, you know, Clay's decision to accept John Quincy Adams' offer of Secretary of State seems it's a really bad look. Whether, you know, I don't think the corrupt bargain has any merit as you know, it's a political tool used to engage Jackson's political supporters. Your the voice of the people has been stolen when in reality you know the politics of the House of Representatives Clay personally had little impact on how the votes came out in in the House. And I think it was no secret going into the contingent election of 1825 after nobody got a majority in 24. I think it was clear Clay's Clay was never gonna be a supporter of Jackson, and less talked about too are Jackson's allies. I'm thinking of people like uh James Buchanan, who later became president about 30 years later. Buchanan was offering Clay the the same deal, which I think doesn't get as much uh traction. Hey, if you swing votes to Jackson's side, he'll give you a place in the cabinet. But I think you touch on something really insightful about Clay, which is this him accepting John Quincy Adams' nomination as Speaker of the House. While it I think it made sense from Clay's point of view, it certainly made sense from John Quincy Adams' point of view, it's one of those really costly political mistakes that dogs Clay all the way to his death in 1852. It's there's other reasons why he loses presidential elections after 1824. But even if there are other reasons, there is always this kind of oh, what's the word? This kind of shade of the corrupt bargain that people aren't really able to get over.
SPEAKER_00Well said, and it it certainly is incredible when you read about I've read I've read this book one time about just how it was Jackson and Van Buren together, really working together to build this party. It's it's really remarkable of how it went from just you know Jackson as as people saw it, right? The the self made man, right? Becoming uh going from himself uh being, I remember that story of that. British officer uh cutting part of his face or something. And then I mean, and not to mention War of 1512, who was a hero. Uh pretty crazy story. But the point is that I that Clay, I think, really uh it seems like he really did see that that big force there of politics that he had to encounter. Uh, but obviously he uh embodies uh where he took on a very important position as speaker, as you just mentioned. What can you tell us about Clay's speakership? Uh how did his time as speaker of the House really change the institution that we know of in the House and in Congress as we understand it and during that time?
SPEAKER_02Well, just real quick, I want to say you just said the term self-made man. That is a term that Henry Clay himself coined. So, I mean, you can see it's he he called himself a self-made man, and he so his influence looms large even over our language.
SPEAKER_00Wow. I just said a clayism there.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Uh, but you're right, his time as speaker of the House of Representatives is going to face some of the most pivotal moments of the first 50 years of the American Republic. Clay was he had already spent some time in the Senate. He filled a couple other senators' terms before, so only a few months at most, but but by the time Clay was elected to the House of Representatives in his own right, he had enough authority, he had enough uh respect that he was he was elected Speaker of the House on his very first day in the House, which is is wild. Yeah, you would not see that in the House of Representatives today. No, you need like 10, 20 years of experience in the House. Uh but no, Clay got it on his first day. Um, and so he gets to see the War of 1812. He actually plays a big role pushing uh James Madison to war with Great Britain. I know we'll talk about it a little bit later, but he helped push through the Missouri Compromise in 1820. And then, last but not least, his time as Speaker of the House during the election of 1824. So Clay realized the potential for the Speaker of the House of Representatives that hadn't been appreciated before. Before Clay, the speakership was more or less uh kind of a parliamentarian rule uh role. You you organize the committees, you organize the debates, you and then you just kind of your job is just to make sure nobody's yelling at each other too much. Um but Clay realized the power that the speakership can hold, and so he's perfectly willing to wield this power. He he organizes committees that will help push his legislative agenda through. He organizes the debates in the house so that way his legislative agenda can go through. I mean, it for a guy who's only in his early 30s, he there's this remarkable savviness about how the House of Representatives should operate that I think is really interesting for a guy who's only been in politics for a decade, maybe, and only if a little bit of that was in federal politics.
SPEAKER_00It reminds me of just the comparison between the American system and the British system, where in the British system, which is still the case to this day, the speaker really is that person who is effectively just trying to tell people to not yell, or at least not yell too loudly that people can't hear. And uh I imagine that there's a part of me and this point, but if I were a speaker of the house and that was the only thing I was doing, just kind of playing traffic cop, it would be wouldn't be very interesting, right? Because it's like, you know, I'm the speaker of the house. I'm speaking on behalf of the whole institution, in this case the House of Commons, if you're in the British side. But uh, I imagine that the the maybe maybe Clay just felt like, you know, we need to bring some action here, you know, as the speaker.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And Clay, I mean, he he takes advantage of that. He he likes uh organizing the house as a committee of the whole, so he can not not only can he vote, he can go in and he can give speeches. Uh and it gets him in trouble a bit, but he he liked this, he realized the potential that the highest ranking officer in the House of Representatives could have.
SPEAKER_00There's obviously a number of different ways that people talk about slavery, right? There's kind of the there there certainly is that moral element, right? Of course, we all understand that it is a moral standard, of course, for slavery. But there's also at that time people talking about the economics of it. They were talking about all kinds of different the politics of it too. Uh it started really stemming from the early days of our our country, right? The Declaration and the Constitution. So where does Clay fit into these debates of how he how he brokers these compromises as well? Because that's not no matter, obviously, we can look back over hindsight's 2020, but that's it's not easy to do in that in that kind of environment.
SPEAKER_02No, it's not. And by 1820, there are there's starting to be rumblings where Missouri wants to be admitted to the Union as a slave state. And ultimately the conversation becomes well, what do we do with all this federal territory in the West that we got in the Louisiana Purchase? And for the first time, you have Southerners saying, if we don't get anything out of these new federal territories, we might have to secede from the Union. And you know, this is the moment where Thomas Jefferson, you know, in the twilight of his life, writes that you know the Missouri crisis is a firebell in the night. We are creating a dividing line through which the rest of in his mind American history will be fought through. And Clay recognized that, and so he he didn't come up with the Missouri Compromise Line of 3630 that split the Louisiana territory free and slave. That was proposed by another member of Congress, but he pushed it through because he realized this is not good. If one section of the nation secedes, the inevitable result is civil war, and there is no good that will come from that. And so he pushed through the Missouri Compromise, and for better or worse, that was sort of political orthodoxy for the next 30-34 years. The idea that this territory there is a place where slavery is allowed, but above it will be permanently and forever free. This is something that people did not challenge too much until the 1850s. By the time you get to 1850, though, the mood the national mood is a lot more tense. Uh the stakes became even higher. Not only were Southerners saying we might have to secede if we don't get anything from in at that point in time, it's the the southwest of the United States, New Mexico, Arizona, that that area. Southerners were meeting in Nashville to make their list of demands to the federal government. You will give us Western lands, or we will secede. The uh government of Texas claimed that it had control over Santa Fe, New Mexico, and so the state of Texas is raising up an army to invade the federal territory. Meanwhile, at the time, President Zachary Taylor really wasn't providing that much leadership, and so there's this vacuum that Clay hoped to fill in. At this point, he's 73, he's dying of tuberculosis. He's only he only has about a year and a half, two years left to live. He's not really anticipating another presidential run. And so he he uh forms a committee on slavery in the territories, including uh a young Stephen A. Douglas of Lincoln Douglas debate fame, and they come up with this compromise. The compromise is going to have five parts. California, flush with new people from the California gold rush, will come into the Union as a free state, something for the free states, the unorganized Western territories would be organized into uh the Utah Territory and then the New Mexico Territory. And so they would but the federal government would say nothing about whether they are slave or free. So that way, if they wanted to be a slave territory, slave state, that would be something that local law would have to determine. So kind of a gift to both. Texas, in exchange for backing down against its territorial claims, would get uh basically get its debts paid off from from when it was a republic. The slave trade was abolished in the District of Columbia, slavery still continued, but now congressmen wouldn't have to worry about seeing uh coffles of enslaved people right next to the you know the Temple of Liberty, as some called it. And then the sort of final piece of this was a stricter fugitive slave law. Fugitive slave laws are built into the U.S. Constitution, they were approved in the 1790s, shortly after the Constitution's ratification. But to ensure that the Southerners, especially those in the Deep South fire eaters is what they were called, had a little bit more to appeal to them. These this fugitive slave law was stricter, it was harsher. Uh, federal agents and federal judges going after accused fugitives would be paid twice as much to declare somebody a slave than to declare somebody a free person. The accused would have no rights to an individual trial or a defense. And Clay hoped that he could offer all of this up as a single grand bargain. You know, we you'll sometimes hear in the news of an omnibus package. You know, that comes from the compromise of 1850, just like how uh a bus has all these people gathered together going in the same direction, so too would this omnibus have all these components for the grand compromise. Sadly, though, the omnibus failed to get passed. So Clay left the Senate to basically go to a health retreat. He more or less is demoralized. Fortunately, Stephen A. Douglas repackaged the deals and offered them to Congress as separate measures, and those eventually get passed by you know shifting majorities, shifting margins. Though Douglass was made sure to credit once this all got passed, he's like, look, these are fundamentally what Clay offered, what Henry Clay offered. This just happened to have been passed in this more roundabout way.
SPEAKER_00I appreciate what you said there about the circumstances. Clay seemed like he was stuck between a rock and a hard place, as was everyone else. Um and he, you know, I I can I forget the fact that he was at that age as well, as age of 73. I I wanted to now step back, Jacob, in terms of looking at the presidential election, because we're talking about legislation, about Clay's involved in this legislation. Then he gets involved in presidential campaigns, which at least to me uh seems like a very odd thing relating to like on top of well, first of all, doesn't make your schedule any uh any less busy, so uh that doesn't give him more vacation time in that sense.
SPEAKER_02And second of all, I don't get the sense that Clay really enjoyed vacations. I think he he he liked sort of this active lifestyle.
SPEAKER_00So I mean uh honestly the there's a virtue to keep yourself busy and keeping active.
SPEAKER_02Um love what you do, you never work a day in your life.
SPEAKER_00That's right, exactly. And uh if Hawaii was a state at that time, maybe maybe you would have taken the taken the because they're like, oh, okay, maybe Sandy Beach is all there. I I uh I I I think I really want to ask about this because it does seem like it's such a big, a very different thing than what he's already been doing in the house. So what can you just tell us about the the different presidential campaigns that he ran and and why do you think he he made those leaps, even though it seems like it would counter the the kind of person he was and the kind of influence he was already wielding in the house?
SPEAKER_02The current meme is that there are two wolves inside somebody, right? And Clay had these two wolves inside him, one of which is this kind of enlightened patriotism. He has a quote that he famously said, I'd rather be right than president. But on the other hand, he also has this incredible ambition. Yeah, he'd like to be right, but he'd also really like to be president. Uh there's a story of he finds out that he lost the nomination. I believe it was to William Henry Harrison. And he's informed by it. Mr. Clay, you know, General Harrison has won the Whig nomination for the presidency. And Clay had already drunk a little bit, and he says something along the lines of, well, if only there were two Henry Clays, because one would then make the other president. So Clay has this remarkable ambition, and he he makes this leap into presidential politics because of that ambition and because he thinks he can do good. And so he runs five times, he ran in 1824, where he landed in last place out of four candidates. He attempted to run against Andrew Jackson in 1832, but Jackson was able to mobilize opposition to the National Bank, which was seen as this you know corrupt corporation that was stealing from the American people against Clay effectively, and Clay sadly got got beaten pretty heavily. He tried again for the Whig nomination in 1840. But by 1840, the Whig party realized okay, clearly Henry Clay, with his years of service and reputation and record to run on is a liability. So they went with William Henry Harrison, uh son of a signer of Declaration of Independence, uh, but he was famous as a war hero during the War of 1812. And so they package William Henry Harrison as the Whig version of Andrew Jackson. Harrison wins, and Clay is obviously mad because he's like, Well, I could have won that. 1844, the Whigs are they nominate him, and 1844 is actually probably the most tragic out of Clay's election defeats because it's so incredibly narrow. A few votes in a few different places really would have changed the result, and so it really makes you wonder what would have happened had Clay won in 1844. Would there have been the annexation of Texas the following year? Would there have been a war against Mexico in 1846? How would he have handled maybe something like the compromise of 1850 from the presidential angle if he had been in office? It's it's a really interesting question, and so you know, we we we just can't know. Uh then in 1848, Clay thought, oh, okay, clearly this Mexican war is going bad. Clearly, James K. Polk is doing a bad job. This is this is my moment. The problem is, is the Whigs are like, hold on, we're in the middle of a war. And Clay gave a speech in 1847 critical of the war. We know that's not gonna fly well with the American public. So we need a war hero, preferably a war hero from the Mexican War, and preferably a war hero from the Mexican War, who doesn't have any political beliefs, doesn't have any political uh ideology, and that comes in the form of Zachary Taylor, and so the Whigs are able to say to the North, Oh, yeah, you don't understand. Zachary Taylor opposes the expansion of slavery into the territories in the South. No, no, no, Southerners, you see, uh Taylor supports expanding slavery into the federal territories. To loyal Whigs, they say, ah, you know, Taylor is a good loyal Whig. He didn't vote in 1844, but if he did, he would have voted for Henry Clay. To the Democrats, they say, ah, you see, uh, Zachary Taylor has never voted a day in his life. In fact, he is so removed from politics that he won't he'll make sure that basically everybody gets a seat at the table. He's not going to discriminate based off of political party. And this really frustrates Clay and many Whigs because they once again we we want this party to mean something. If this party has to be more than just winning an election Zachary Taylor wins, and you know, Clay once again is like and by that point Clay largely checked out of presidential politics. Not only had he lost the presidency, To Zachary Taylor, or the Whig nomination for the presidency, to Zachary Taylor. His son, his frankly, his favorite son, Henry Clay Jr., died at the Battle of Buena Vista. Clay effectively sort of gives up. He goes, you know what? Clearly, I'm gonna check out from politics a bit. And he he comes back in 1849 to the Senate in response to the upcoming crisis that that sort of threatens the nation that needs the compromise of 1850.
SPEAKER_00And imagine Clay is just like, man, it's just it feels like every time I run running against a war hero.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Wow. I didn't know about that about 1848 because I only knew what the matchup was between a Taylor and Lewis Cass, the Democrat. Uh, but I didn't know exactly what the dynamics looked like, especially as Polk said he was not going to run for another term. He was just going to do this one term and go. Uh now, Jacob, I wanted to touch upon the connection real quick between Clay and of course another Kentucky boy, uh Lincoln. I I say Kentucky boy because he was he was born in Kentucky, and I know Illinois wants to take credit for him, Nevada certainly does, and and all that. I think he's he run I I would I'm gonna be the nice guy to say he there's a part of Lincoln in there in all those different states, but he is uh from Kentucky. And so what can you share about the connection between Clay and Lincoln?
SPEAKER_02So there's a few connections. Clay or Lincoln grew up and became an an admirer of Clay. As Lincoln entered politics, he was heavily influenced by Clay. He uh, one of his earliest speeches, where he announces he's he wants to be elected to something, Lincoln says something along the lines of, My politics are short and sweet, like the old woman's dance. And he then lists the American system. He says, I want a national bank, protective tariff, uh internal improvements. And he called Clay his bow ideal of a statesman. Now, this was very fortunate for Lincoln because in Springfield, Illinois, in the late 1830s, a young woman named Mary Todd moved to Springfield who had a personal connection with Clay. And so through his relationship with Mary, there he has now a there's no evidence that Lincoln and Clay ever met, but certainly through his wife, Mary grew up in Lexington, Kentucky, just three miles down from the Ashton estate. She knew Henry Clay, she her father was a Kentucky Whig like Clay. And in fact, there's family stories that Mary had a little bit of a schoolgirl crush on Henry Clay. Uh so Lincoln and Clay just they really unite in this ideological and emotional way with you know with Lincoln. He remains a loyal Whig essentially until the last minute. He he really does not want to jump ship from the Whig Party until it's clear the party's going nowhere, which is when he jumps to the Republicans in uh 56. But there's an interesting story about this influence that I think really demonstrates the connection of ideology and his family. So I alluded to the market speech that Clay gave in 1847 against the Mexican War. This was in November of 1847, and uh Lincoln, his wife, and at that point their two children happened to be in Lexington, Kentucky, staying with Mary's family just a few blocks away from the market. We have no once again, no direct evidence that Lincoln was ever at this speech, but for a man who idolized Clay, to know that basically uh the guy he admires most is just a few blocks away giving a speech from the house that he's staying at, and his father-in-law, Robert Todd, organi was one of the organizers for the speech. It's like come on, he had to have been there. Uh but in in the speech, Clay mentions how the Mexican War was illegal, unjust. It was uh the American people were lied to it at the start of this war. The contents of that speech seem to have influenced Lincoln heavily because just a few weeks later, Lincoln goes to the House of Representatives, and in one of his early speeches, as a first-term congressman, it's about opposition to the Mexican War. And what does he do? He sort of parrots these points that Clay made just like I said, just a couple of weeks earlier. And Clay or Lincoln's speech gets panned, uh and the Whigs of Sangamon County, Illinois say, You're good with one term. We're not we're not sending you back. So that influence is so strong for Lincoln that he certainly willing to risk his own political future, his own political stakes to sort of carry the banner of Henry Clay.
SPEAKER_00Somehow, uh, which I've I've if I were in Illinois as a voter there, I'd be pretty upset with that. But nonetheless, uh I think there's so much to that connection. And I'm glad that Jacob you highlighted the that Mary Todd connection and you know there's that saying, you know, behind every strong man is a stronger woman. And so I think demonstrated that. Uh uh Jacob, now I want to give you an opportunity to wrap up the Clay part of our conversation before we get to reflecting our on these topics there. How should we understand Clay's legacy on not just 19th-century American politics, but on how we understand civics and our Congress, which should be, as we we always say, should be the people's house.
SPEAKER_02And I think I'm gonna start with his influence on 19th century politics. I mean, the he looms large over this era. Uh he out basically second only to Andrew Jackson. And I think it says something that even after his death, you know, for the decade between his death and the Civil War, his name is always brought up. We need another Clay, we need Henry Clay to come in. You have his proteges, the people he's mentored throughout his life. Uh, Abraham Lincoln is the most famous one. Uh, but uh John J. Crittenden, a fellow Kentuckian, as the Civil War is about to happen, Crittenden tries to create another one of these grand compromises in 1861, hoping if we just come up with a compromise, everything will be okay. And you know, Clay Clay, I think, brought this really great aspect to Congress, which is you know, you mentioned the unpopularity of Congress now. Uh I would be terrified to find out the viewership numbers of something like C-SPAN, but for you know, Clay is one of these great orators. You know, you mentioned him alongside Daniel Webster. This was an attraction. You go to DC and you you go and you see Clay give a speech, and he was able to create so even people who hated him or disagreed with him, they they were kind of drawn to him. Uh John Randolph of Roanoke, a guy who clay got into a duel with in the 1820s. He's he's dying, and he he asks to come to the Senate to see Henry Clay give a speech so that way he could hear Clay speak one last time. In 1842, when Clay resigns from the Senate, yeah, oh I need I want to spend more time with my family and my farm, that sort of thing. Really, he wants to run for president in 44. John C. Calhoun, a guy known as the cast iron man, starts, you know, he's getting choked up as Clay is leaving. He's he actually starts crying, and he he he's grumbling to himself. He's like, uh, you know, he's he's a drinker, he's a gambler, he's all these sorts of things, and he's like, But by God, I love him. Yeah, it's just clay has this remarkable effect on the people around him, where honestly, unless unless you're Andrew Jackson, people love him. And as we go further in American history, his influence is still felt today. Look at uh for any of your listeners, look at the map of your state. I guarantee there's a clay county. For there's an Ashland county. These are all tracing themselves back to Clay. Even in the 1950s, Clay was listed as one of the top five greatest senators in American history, alongside Daniel Webster, John C. Calhoun, and I forget who the other two are, but uh I mean the fact that after a hundred years, this guy still is at the top. When uh it's very hard to escape who Clay was and what he did for the nation. And there's some people who even said in 1860, 1861 that maybe if Clay was still alive, maybe we wouldn't have a civil war. Maybe, maybe not, but it it says something that they thought that way.
SPEAKER_00Indeed, and that is the alternate history that people like myself want to know so badly. And and obviously there's a lot of components to it, but I imagine that however this things would have occurred, whether or not there'd be a civil war, it it is important to reflect on some what someone has done for an institution, whether we have disagreements and all, I think there is a civic element to that. And my my hope is that even as people will have all kinds of agreements, disagreements about whoever in the Senate or the House that we understand as an institution and that it does require people who believe in it, who believe in the power and who are doing good things with it, of course. And so, Jacob, I want to now reflect on our conversation today. We've we talked all kinds of different aspects. I appreciate what you have brought to us about Clay and his legs and what he means to your state, what it means to our country. Reflecting on some of these principles of Watchman's farewell address, so looking at patriotism, faith, national unity, education, fiscal responsibility, and civility, lots of different uh components here. What values of among those do you think are most pertinent to our conversation about Clay and to our understanding of him?
SPEAKER_02So, first of all, Clay would appreciate you putting him alongside George Washington. Clay was an incredible admirer of Washington. If you ever visit the Ashland estate here in Lexington, Clay was given a huge painting of Washington and his family. He had a glass that Washington had uh during the revolution. And during during the compromise of 1850 debates, Clay had a little piece of George Washington's coffin that he would use as a prop to explain national unity. So he would be very flattered that you put the two of them in conversation. But to answer the question, national unity, I think, was would be the theme that really meant the most to Clay, especially by 1850. His whole life had been trying to keep the nation together. Most famously, the compromises over slavery. If we can prevent civil war, the nation will be able to survive, freedom will be able to expand as long as the union is together. But in a more pragmatic sense, the American system is designed to unify the nation. So Clay's goal throughout his life was for the Union not only to stay together, but to grow stronger. And that Americans can be closer together than they were a generation before. Is making sure that the compromise of 1850, as imperfect as it was for many people, he wanted it to be clear. This is the last settlement. Come on, guys, let's stop fighting about this. We cannot keep fighting because only bad things result. And I think that's just the the theme that follows his career. Alongside his ambition, alongside his his own uh personal foibles, his drinking, his gambling. It's this even the American system, Clay he didn't like it, but he was perfectly willing to disregard parts of the American system if he thought it would unify the nation together. One of the reasons South Carolina in the early 1830s was able to back down from nullification and potentially secession, Clay compromised on the tariff. He said, fine, if this is that big of a deal, let's step back. We'll gradually lower the tariff to make sure that South Carolina doesn't go too far. And so I, you know, this guy I think really would appreciate his legacy being known as the great compromiser or the great pacificator, the guy who brought peace to the nation.
SPEAKER_00Well said. And you encourage everybody to visit Lexington and Frankfurt.
SPEAKER_02Yes, absolutely. Central Kentucky is fantastic.
SPEAKER_00So it's a beautiful state, and I recommend people to go visit that state. And uh whether it's Louisville or you go to Lexington, it just absolutely amazes. Exactly, exactly. Now, uh Jacob, before we go, I want to give you an opportunity to share about what can people do to learn more about KHS?
SPEAKER_02So the best way to learn about the Kentucky Historical Society is to visit us. We have three different museums on our campus in downtown Frankfurt. We have our flagship building, the Thomas D. Clark Center for Kentucky History. We have the old state capital that you mentioned, our state capitol from for most of the 1800s. And we have the Kentucky Military History Museum. However, since I know this is a national reaching podcast, if you cannot visit us in person, we certainly encourage your listeners to uh go to our website, history.ky.gov. Uh it's a really robust website with a lot of information and resources, and you get to see some of the some of the great things my colleagues are up to. For me specifically, uh with the Civil War Governors of Kentucky project, my division in in KHS, uh, I strongly recommend your listeners also give us a look. We have about 10,000 documents that your listeners can view for free. They are transcribed, they are annotated, they have little biographies of the different people, places, things. Because we really want with the Civil War governors of Kentucky project to use the office of the governors as a lens to learn more about how Kentuckians lived during the Civil War era, how they dealt with things like violence, emancipation. And all of that is freely available on our website, discovery.org.
SPEAKER_00And I'll make sure to put those links down in the show notes below for people to access. Jacob Wood, thank you so much for coming to our podcast. I really appreciate it.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much. I'm so glad to be here.
SPEAKER_00Thank you all so much for listening to this episode. I hope you enjoyed it. Make sure to check out the links down in the show notes below. Have a great rest of your day and rest of your week. And remember, a day in America is always better. We are with our friends and fellows.