Friends & Fellow Citizens
In this unique civics podcast, discover how the principles of George Washington's Farewell Address (patriotism, civility, faith, education, national unity, and fiscal responsibility) apply to today! With a focus on American political institutions and policymaking, hear fascinating stories and discussions that any America-loving listener can enjoy!
This non-partisan podcast is a remarkable mix of solo shows, interviews and special guests that gives you a great boost of freedom! New episodes on the first two Mondays of each month!
Friends & Fellow Citizens
#213: Conserving Environmental Stewardship for Greener Pastures feat. Gabriella Hoffman, Hannah Downey
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
When most people think of environmental protection in this day and age of volatile weather and political climate, they think of government interventionism, coercion, and agencies.
But with the right incentives, is government always the answer? Or are there solutions that make economic and sustainability sense to foster environmental stewardship instead of coercion?
We are delighted to be joined by Hannah Downey, Associate VP of Policy at PERC, and Gabriella Hoffman, a freelance journalist and podcast host. They share with us the many ways American policymakers can use market-based incentives to achieve realistic energy outcomes and make citizens want to participate and protect the environment.
Learn more about PERC at perc.org!
Check out Gabriella's podcast District of Conservation!
Visit georgewashingtoninstitute.org to sign up for our e-mail list! The site is the one-stop shop of all things Friends & Fellow Citizens and George Washington Institute!
JOIN as a Patreon supporter and receive a FREE Friends & Fellow Citizens mug at the $25 membership level!
IMPORTANT NOTE/DISCLAIMER: All views expressed by the host are presented in his personal capacity and do not officially represent the views of any affiliated organizations. All views presented by guests are solely those of the interviewees themselves and may or may not represent the views of their affiliated organizations, the host, Friends & Fellow Citizens, and/or The George Washington Institute.
Patriotism, faith, national unity, education, physical responsibility, civility, the values that define America. Fascinating stories and talks from America-loving patriots dedicated to preserving freedom, opportunity, and justice. Welcome to the Friends and Fellow Citizens Podcast. Hello, everybody. Welcome to another episode here on Friends and Fellow Citizens. I'm your host, Sherman Tailowski. Thank you all so much for joining me in this interview episode. We've got a lot to cover here. We're going to be talking about conservation as a civic value. It's something that I think we can all rally around because we all care about the environment. We want our environment to be in a better place. But what are the best ways to do that through our institutions, through our policymaking, so that we really bring out the best and the innovation and the creativity out of our country? That's what we're going to be talking about today. Before we get to our content, first of all, a big shout out and thank you to our dedicated Patreon supporters. They help to keep the show going and are so incredibly generous with their contributions. So if you want to be part of a podcast that values American traditions, such as patriotism, like civility, like national unity, like fiscal responsibility, become a part of our podcast and join our membership here in the Patreon page down in the show notes below. Without further ado, I'm going to introduce our two guests here who will be joining us momentarily. So the first guest is Hannah Downey. She is the Associate Vice President of Policy at Property and Environment Research Center known as PERC, PERC, leading policy strategy and government affairs efforts to implement key policy reforms based on PERC's groundbreaking research. She has applied her passion for the outdoors to advance lasting conservation wins since joining PERC in 2015. Hannah has testified before Congress and works closely with policymakers at the federal and state levels on conservation issues, and her work has been featured in media outlets including the Wall Street Journal and The Hill. We are also joined by Gabriella Hoffman. Gabriella is a media strategist, consultant, freelance journalist, a policy analyst, and award-winning outdoor writer based in the Washington, D.C. metro area. She is primarily focusing on her role as director of the Center for Energy and Conservation at the Independent Women's Forum while juggling her business on a part-time freelance basis. She also hosts the weekly District of Conservation podcast and returned to Townhall.com as a freelance columnist in summer twenty twenty. Without further ado, let's get right into our episode. All right, everybody, I'm very excited to welcome Gabriella and Hannah onto the podcast. Ladies, thank you so much for joining us today.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Sherman, for having us. Yeah, absolutely. So excited to be here.
SPEAKER_01Well, uh, I just want to first say that uh it was gr it's been great to coordinate and put this together. Obviously, as we were chatting earlier, there's so much to talk about on the environment as we're seeing the wildfires in Canada and in Europe and um and all these conversations about energy and whatnot. So there's a lot to to get into. But I'd just like to first say that uh first of all to Gabriella, it's so great to talk with you again. It's the first time since we met in person at Freedom Fest back in 2022 in Vegas. So great to connect there and hope uh hope you're gonna be doing a lot of things and uh with the podcast and all. And of course, Hannah, great to meet you virtually in person. I think this is really wonderful and so glad that both of you have uh this connection already as friends and and working on such on such important issues. Uh I'm gonna start with Gabriella and uh Gabriella, would you mind introducing yourself and uh talk a bit more about what it is that you do as the director of the Center for Energy and Conservation at the Independent Women's Forum. So just talk about that and uh kind of how how your perspective of a as a journalist and a media strategist uh can add value to the to policy on energy the energy and environment um discourse that we're seeing here today.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you, Sherman, for the opportunity to chat. And that was a crazy year for young voices. I remember getting sick at that Vegas forum, and everyone was still kind of hungover with with the COVID stuff. Uh, but I went into a pool at the Mirage, got sunstroke, and that's why I got sick. So that's that's an aside. But uh I I come from the West. Um I'm a first generation American, so I feel like I have a very interesting perspective as a first generation American. My parents came from the former Soviet Union, which had no regard for the environment whatsoever with central planning policies. And coming from California, I have a great appreciation for the great outdoors. And I come from uh I come to energy policy and conservation policy a little bit differently than some others. I would say from my involvement in the outdoor industry and the hook and bullet crowd. And I always had like an interest in public policy, but in college it was kind of suppressed because I didn't feel ideologically I was allowed to say something as a conservative. It was very left-leaning when I went to UC San Diego. Um, but something that Ann had made me very early on was I learned that fishing access had been closed in much of the Southern California coast under the guise of environmental protections. Those were supposed to be temporary, they said. And I did some digging and I found that that was very unsettling. Um, never saw that access restored in from that time. I I've always been keen on investigating kind of these dynamics with conservation policy and access and even how it translates to energy. And I think coming from the hook and bullet crowd can make you as informed to see what happens with other uses if you're talking about public waters and public lands. And Hannah has a great foray into that too, and I don't want to take too much from her. Uh, but I come from a similar uh policy background like her, even though I would say a lot of my focus now is on the energy question, but I still dabble into a lot of the lands uh and waters usage issues as well, because that's something that uh we try to talk about when you're producing, uh, whether energy or agriculture, you're also having to account for, and you should account for conservation practices. We don't have to trade one for the other. Um, so that's something that's always guided my philosophy as a conservative conservationist and even translating into my work. And I think we now see, uh, which we'll talk more about, um, this this notion of abundance, I think is a great antidote to like degrowth and and net zero. Um, people are warming up to that uh label a lot more and they're seeing it more positively and how you can have abundance, you could have all this productivity while also caring for your natural surroundings. So I think um that's what I tried to channel as director of IW's Center for Energy and Conservation, showcasing that you could be multifarious, multi-purposed. Um, and and that's the American way. And I know Hannah's gonna talk more about that as well, uh, because a lot of people used to see conservation as like a top-down approach rather than a bottom-up or um no individuals. It had to be guided by the government. But now we see a lot of individuals um, you know, trying to fix situations. We see stalemates with permitting reform, forest management, and you look to the private sector and individuals, and they're helping to bring some remedies out there, which are now being adopted by the government under this administration in particular. Um, so you see the private sector individuals influencing from the outside in to help make uh you know retake possible, reform possible. And we had not seen that in environmentalism up into the last decade or two. And so we're we're trying to chronicle that. We're trying to translate uh difficult energy uh topics and conservation topics into simple, digestible, readable um documents, materials, and the like. And I do a lot of newsmaking. I have fellows that work under me. And you alluded to earlier, um, separate of my work at IW, I still do a podcast. I've had that for about eight, nine years. So try to translate those issues uh in simple terms and interview newsmakers like Hannah and others uh that are in my orbit to kind of talk about what's happening. Um so that's kind of the long and short end of what I do, a lot of things, but yeah, I would say uh much of my time is wonderfully focused on what we do at IW. Um, people know us for a lot of different issues, economics, women's sports, things of that sort. But we've been around for 30-something years. We've dabbled into energy policy a lot, um, more seriously had gotten into it in the last five years. So it's it's great to home the center. It's great to work with people like Hannah, speak with folks like you, Sherman, uh, about our work. So I'm gonna kick it to Hannah to explain who she is.
SPEAKER_01Yep, sounds good. And uh Hannah, uh same same qu same similar question, you did just talk about uh the uh property environment research center, also known as PERC. So maybe talk about the perks of PERC, I should say, and then uh and then talk about your role as the associate vice president of policy there and and specifically where you are, because uh course we we talk a lot about policy in terms of national policy, talk a lot about DC, but you are all based in Montana. So what is it like to not only be involved in the policy that involves outdoors, but to actually live in the outdoors while promoting conservation policy?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thank you. And and thank you so much for having me and the opportunity to talk with you both. It's it's truly such an honor. Uh so as mentioned, I'm the associate vice president of policy at PERC. Uh PERC is an over 45-year-old conservation research institute uh based in Bozeman, Montana. We are the nation's leader in thinking about uh market-based solutions to conservation challenges. Uh so we have this really wonderful team where we look at uh we base a lot of our work in it's foundational in our research, and then we apply that to conservation policy and practice. So, as Gabrielle mentioned, uh, where she does a lot of kind of energy space and the conservation space, PRC is unique. We're focused solely on kind of land, water, and wildlife. Uh, so we look at how can we use these market-based tools, incentives, property rights, uh, individuals, bottom-up approaches, this locally led solutions to really usher in the next era of conservation. So we truly look at it and say, how do we achieve better outcomes for land, water, and wildlife by using these innovative tools, recognizing that now is the time to be to be embracing this new approach to conservation, to be actually getting results rather than just kind of basing everything in rhetoric. So there's a lot of opportunity for collaboration, a lot of opportunity to be working across the space. Um, and so with my role again as the policy uh running a lot of our policy work, we work with both state and federal policymakers at uh the legislative level, um, agencies, governor's offices, executive level to try and build that cohesion uh to have really sound policymaking. Oftentimes that looks like, as Gabriela mentioned, how do we get government out of out of the way? How do we make it possible for people to be doing good things on the ground? How do we speed up rather than slow down conservation, restoration, uh, and these needed tools? Um, oftentimes it looks like incentivizing positive results. Um, at PERC, we really pride ourselves on leaning into the private sector rather than leaning on big government programs. But how do we harness private dollars, private efforts, uh, conservation partners, industry partners in order to have conservation make economic sense? Oftentimes it's really easy for us to have an emotional reaction to something like a grizzly bear or conserving endangered species or whatever it might be. But there are real-world impacts for the people who live on the ground. And so at PERC, we try and say, how do we align the policies, the practices, the incentives so that the conservation actually happens on the ground and we're not just, you know, publishing white papers for the sake of publishing white papers. But as Gabriello said really elegantly, being able to take these complex ideas, take these complex policies, boil it down, and make sure that everything's working well together. Um, as you mentioned, Sherman, one of our great benefits is that PERC is based in Bozeman, Montana. We have fellows uh and some staff kind of around the country, but our headquarters is here in Bozeman, looking out my window right now. I see national forests, I see mountainscapes, I have uh a white, a beautiful white-tailed buck that like loves to hang out outside my window and will frequently startle me when I look over my shoulder at the end of a meeting or up from reading a paper. Uh, so it's so incredible to be able to have all of this directly here. And it makes it all so personal. By being in Montana, um, like I I I were affected by wildfire smoke. I know it's a bad, scary thing when it's making it to DC, but that's every year for us. It's just so common. Uh, it's unfortunate that it's becoming more common in DC too, but it's these there's so many of these issues are kind of based in these bigger western landscapes uh that it's really incredible to be able to be based here and see how it plays out on the ground.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's wonderful to hear from both of you. And I think to add on to what you both said, number one, of course, is really the value of our natural world. I mean, I'm here uh based in Carson City, and we're very close to one of the beautiful lakes in not just the entire country, but the entire world of Lake Tahoe and the beautiful Sierra uh forest uh all around. And there there truly is that those gems and those wonders of the world that really bring communities and people together. So I just on that. And then the second thing too is you you both are talking about getting government out of the way. I think that's such an important thing. The last time I checked, I think all of us are part of the environment. So why is government the only thing that we should be coming up with? Uh, we do need government at times, but there did there are times when government is in the way, and I think there is a lot of value to bring the the subject and the topic back to the people in some way, you know, back to uh those who are as citizens, right, as people are part of the democratic process. Uh and I think those are really, really essential to coming up with those solutions there. I want to now get to a question for each of you, and I think this is where uh where I want to start here. We're talking about environmental stewardship here, and it builds on these principles and civics, but I I want to start from the beginning here in terms of conservation and this link with civic engagement. Uh I'll go to Gabrielle first and then to Hannah. Uh uh Gabriel, what does conservation mean to you as part of civic engagement?
SPEAKER_00Conservation to me as part of civic engagement can can mean many things, but I think essentially it's the wise use of natural resources and you, the individual, having a stake in that decision-making process wherever you feel appropriate. So because I buy fishing licenses, hunting licenses, I like to recreate. I try to buy, and I've been trying to buy more frequently national park passes. Because I have a vested interest in wanting to see those landscapes, you know, public resources maintained, I feel like I have to have buy-in. So if you claim to be a conservationist, you want to see the perpetuity of public resources, whether they're, you know, forests, the landscapes, or the wildlife that you admire and oftentimes pursue by not exceeding your quarry and your lot. Your your, you know, when you hunt and fish, you have to go by hunting seasons, bag limits, clear limits, et cetera. Um, I think it's within your duty, you know, as an American citizen to partake in the process, because every time you buy a license, you're contributing to the greater contribution of uh conservation dollars, and we need to see that happen because there's no other alternative, uh, for example, with that. Um so I think, you know, keeping this notion alive of wisely maintaining natural resources, not overdeveloping or not leaving things to become re-wild is essential. And I think more and more Americans are understanding this notion, whether it applies to energy development, agriculture uses, hunting, fishing, outdoor recreation, um, you know, getting involved in the process, having some buy-in is essential. And it'll make you more informed, it'll make you more appreciative of your natural surroundings, and know that things have have to warrant more nuance. Um, not everything is black and white in this situation. And as you get more involved, and Hannah and I have both worked in this space for many, many years now, even though we're still fairly young, uh, but you know, working over a decade or so in the in this space, you you you gain a different insight. You don't change your principles or anything like that. I think you strengthen your conservatism and your support for conservationism. But I think sometimes what gets lost is that extremes uh want to kind of hijack the situation, uh, but you find that the overdevelopment perspective is very limited. Um, most people want to see some you know balance use still. And then the people who are totally for rewilding are on the losing end too, because they often have these other radical notions of uh the world is too overpopulated, you can't have kids to sustain um, you know, conservation, even though if you want to make sure you want to pass you know environmental stewardship to the next generation, you should get married and have kids and pass those traditions on. Um, or if you have nieces or nephews or something of that nature. So you often see in these extremes that none of those extremes are palatable to the wider conservation conversation. So I think having actual buy-in, not coming from afar and trying to lecture to people on the ground what is happening is also essential. So get involved in the process uh really makes you more informed. And then also trying to, you know, come about these conversations organically and not with imposing uh impositions rather, I think is also important too.
SPEAKER_02Sherman, it could I could I jump in on that? Because I think Gabriella made such an important point there. And I oftentimes say, like, I'm an environmentalist, and chances are you are too, right? Like we all want uh clean water, fresh air, uh healthy wildlife populations. Like we kind of all share that at our core. Where I think uh Gabriella and I are coming at this from a unique angle is to say how we do that matters, and the concept of just uh spending money or outsourcing it to the government or someone else, it doesn't get the incentives right to actually get the stewardship right on the ground. And so, as Gabriella mentioned, like her purchasing the hunting and fishing licenses, the park passes, I think what is so exceptional about those structures, and as a little bit of background for listeners here, is that um those are three examples of user fees where the dollars actually go back directly, not to the general treasury, not to Congress to give out, but to the resources and the land managers themselves, right? So when you purchase a park pass, at least 80 100% of the money stays within um, you know, the National Park Service to go to management and maintenance of these lands. But at least 80% of it stays in the individual unit where you are buying that pass. So if you are going to Yellowstone National Park and you are walking on the boardwalks, you're using the restrooms, you're using a picnic facility, you're putting garbage in the in the dumpster, like your visitation has an impact, but through this unique visitor fee mechanism, like your dollars are actually helping fund that. And so to that kind of civic engagement, those are really cool ways where we can tie us as the as the consumer, as the demander of these natural resources to the conservation there. And it's uh it's how we can take some direct ownership in making that happen. So I think that's my biggest piece on all this civic engagement is how do we not only as individuals, but also kind of create the institutions that allow the individuals to be directly engaged instead of trying to outsource everything and hoping that someone else will get it right when we've seen time and time again that outsourcing this back to DC or back to a large bureaucracy isn't gonna get it right.
SPEAKER_01I appreciate what you both said there because uh I guess to not to bring back any PTSD for Gabrielle on the mirage, but maybe a lot of people might think feel like conservation is a bit of a mirage, right? This idea that you know is it is it real? Can we attain it? And and is it possible to get past all the all the partisanship, the polarization, all these things that are happening? And yet what you're both alluding to is that there really is a lot that can bring a lot of people together, right? And go the visitation of national parks. Like who who doesn't want to do that, right? As part of a great vacation. Um, just over here, just watch out for bears, um, because bears bears uh yeah, bear bear bears don't participate in the civics as much as I want them to.
SPEAKER_00Um you never know. One day they can.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Maybe they're more involved in Montana, Hannah. I don't if I just over here in Nevada, I think we're just too libertarian for um for a while.
SPEAKER_02We have a we have a fierce independent streak over here, too. So yeah, good luck.
SPEAKER_01Anyway, I think what you brought both bring here is is so valuable when it comes to uh bringing back the agency, right? Not agency in terms of bureaucracy, but agency in terms of the ability to carry out and to execute uh those civic responsibilities there. Uh so uh Gabrielle, I want to now go to you now uh to talk about the extent that uh uh the conservation is perceived in uh I guess going back to that Mirage um uh Mirage metaphor there, there's there's this there's this one side of the debate and con uh on conservation that is extremely alarmist, right? This idea that because we're in this you know um existential threat, so we're all gonna be consumed by wildfires tomorrow, you know, if the if DC doesn't act right now, and of course DC always acts so promptly, right? Um and but if you know if the big government doesn't come in via the Green New Deal or any something to that matter, then all hope is lost. And there's this kind of that alarmist attitude, or there, I mean, how many, gosh, how many predictions have there been in the past several decades of people saying the world was going to end in 2020 or whatever it was, right? Uh what what what are your thoughts about just um uh the extent that conservationists proceed in that way and how how do you think that perception might be changing in recent years, given uh some of the progress that's been made on uh in not just in government but in the private sector as well?
SPEAKER_00I think legacy environmentalists had a stronghold and kind of a a grapple over the term conservationist for a long time. So a lot of people associate conservation negatively. And with a negative connotation. And I hate to put it into political terms, even though I am a conservative, but I've seen increasingly that this is one of you, like you alluded to earlier, one of the few issues that actually can help bridge the divide. Because who doesn't like going to nature? Who doesn't like having access to national parks, wildlife refuges, monuments, all the different public lands and the type of designations that we have, even with private land opportunities, if you're able to do that too, if you find that you want something more intimate and away from the crowds, that's also a value as well, because we can do both in the United States. Much of the world only has private or very limited opportunities, and there's nothing wrong with private stuff because I'm a free enterprise person. But much of the world doesn't have this luxury of accessing uh public lands. So when you when you hear people say, Well, I'm I'm a conservationist, but I want to create these policies uh under the guise of this notion, but I'm restricting access, or I'm restricting your ability to have a livelihood, or I'm doing this. So to me, that that's always been kind of unsettling because we we have to share under the public kind of notions we have under multiple use management that's been in encoded into law for 50 plus years officially, uh, but even beyond that, um, we've had this notion of balance use for a long, long time. But I think a lot of conservatives were very afraid to wade into this issue because they thought the left had a stranglehold or or um a domination in this issue. So they're like, oh, we'll we'll seed this, we'll cede this to uh issue to the left. And then they're now we're now trying to find our way back into it. But that doesn't mean you can't work with people on you know the center left. I've I've had some friends who are on the center left. I wouldn't say like I work with communists or anyone, DSA types. Uh they're they're a little uh way too out there um with their goals of the Green New Deal, so you won't find commonality with a lot of those folks. But I would say like middle, center left, absolutely, you would find a lot more common ground. So I don't think conservation should be partisan. It has been made sadly partisan, leaning towards the left for many, many years. So now people are actually celebrating the fact that more center right people, conservatives, libertarians, are chiming in on these issues, are getting involved, are using their personal story of whether they're outdoor recreationists like me and Hannah are, um, or maybe they come about it from a different perspective, have a different connection, and find their way into this and sharing their story because storytelling is a very effective means of you know being very, I would say, convincing in this space. And what I've seen, you know, from the public policy side of things to storytelling, when you're conveying your story and you're relating to the greater policy questions or the policy challenges that arise from these issues, um, people can kind of trust you and look to you and see, like, okay, you have a very unique perspective where I didn't know this about a public policy. For one instance, Hannah is probably following this very closely too. But um in the recent weeks, uh the Trump administration announced that they're diminishing a monument in Utah and also I I believe both are in Utah. I can't remember where Grand Staircase has goes. I think it is in Utah as well. I've I've only been to Barry's years, I haven't been to Grand Staircase. Um, but there's this law that was great. It was signed into law by Theodore Roosevelt, the Antiquities Act of 1906. But in the hundred plus years it's been in effect, we don't know what type of presidential authority should be awarded to this. Can a president, you know, designate something? Do they have the power to diminish something? Is a diminishment bad? Are all enlargements good? So in the social media space we have now, we can't have a nuanced conversation about this. It's always like, oh my gosh, this is happening, or oh, I don't want to get to the red meat of this because I don't want to, or oh, this is an attack and an affront on all public lands. And as someone who supports public lands wholeheartedly, I want to see some clarity to this law. That doesn't mean you don't have opportunities because I've seen with enlargements, just for the quick summary for your audience, with enlargements, you often see hunting and fishing not respected as scientific management tools. So to me, that's pretty unsettling, even though the law says that when you're protecting antiquities, you should also respect other forms of scientific management as well. And and what do those antiquities uh preservation maneuvers look like? Is it is it really protecting antiquities or is it just blocking access altogether? So, um, to your question, you know, I I like to see more nuance. I I think it's important to um understand that these are not black and white issues, that there's a lot of uh you know, questions and debate that that surround this, and and cooler heads have to prevail because everything is so alarmist about okay, you're you're diminishing a monument or uh you're relying for more production of this energy source, and it's gonna cause, let's say, like a nuclear war uh if we're talking about nuclear energy, although more people are warming up to nuclear energy, cross-partisanship, cross-gender, cross-age group, because they see that it's feasible to build smaller prototypes and it works 24-7, it's actually zero emissions and it's good for the environment, and you're not using so much land, um, especially when you're talking about other forms of energy that are touted as climate solutions. Wind and solar are actually not so good when you think of um the land output that they use. And then they're still backed up by supposedly evil fossil fuels. So if you're moving away from this, if you're transitioning, why are you still using that? That's not what I agree with, but that's just their argument. Um so you have to look at things, you know, in that way because it it demands for such. Like there's so many trade-offs, and you have to assess trade-offs, and people are very, you know, selective as to what trade-offs they assess. Are you fully assessing trade-offs to a policy decision, whether it relates to energy production, conservation reforms, et cetera, et cetera? And if you're not looking at the trade-offs equally or you're very selective about what those trade-offs could be, I think it doesn't make you well informed. And I think with everything being so hyperpartisan, and now it's creeping into conservation, unfortunately, too, um, we see, you know, people from the outside trying to hijack the issue. We see some legacy environmentalists still using their Malthusian perspective, saying the world is gonna end. But more and more people are demanding, you know, a middle ground approach to what that looks like. And like I said, this destroy everything perspective is largely um, you know, relegated to minority status. I I don't think more than maybe 5% of the population believes in like chopping down all trees, clearing all national parks, and and making everything into like, I don't know, a resort, or like you think of Yellowstone of trying to clear, clear ranch lands that border public lands and and and create that. There are no grip there are not so many like greedy developers like that that want to totally up-end, you know, balance use too much. You do find them, um, and and they may exist, but it's it's largely um not not as threatening, I would say, as like kind of the preservationist thing here. Um, so I think you have to look to that. Uh assess the trade-offs, um, go to the ground, talk to the people, because sometimes a lot of these loud voices are not representative of the people on the ground, and and especially at West. So you have to kind of do your own research. You have to look to see, like, okay, maybe there can be some reforms to the law. Like, can changing a law make it better? Can you allow for more things to happen? So I think that's what Hannah and I both work on uh slightly differently and slightly, you know, using different tools um and maneuvers. But I think it's important to look at conservation like that and not in this like rewalding no-touch, let nature return to pre-human settlement, because humans have always had a positive uh impact on the landscape. Hannah, I was actually reading through Perk's uh 250 report this past weekend, catching up on my reading, and I really appreciated that perspective, I forget who it was, of your colleagues who wrote about that, but they they emphasize that humans have always been part of the landscape, now even more increasingly, and and we have to view those contributions, especially since the 20th century, in a more positive way, because we we recognize we were decimating bison herds, we were hunting to extirpation a lot of commonly seen species like white-tailed deer, as you were alluding to. Um, so now we have this kind of reverse happening where people are not hunting things to extirpation, there's hunting seasons, you're wanting to preserve things, so you see a lot more things even being super abundant with the increase in economic productivity, more free enterprise hopefully coming to the forefront. So uh though those different interests don't have to be um sacrificed for one another there. So I think conservation policy will evolve as we become more prosperous, and we don't have to necessarily give up um maintenance or preservation of the environment, conservation of the environment as we start to become more productive.
SPEAKER_01And and Hannah uh uh Hannah I'll get to you in a sec uh because I want to talk about the market incentives there. Uh, but just a couple things on uh Gabrielle, what you said that I think is important. You're talking a bit about institutions, well, about the partisanship and all. I I completely agree. I think there is that partisanship that's creeping in. I also think that what's interesting is when we talk about institutional decay, this idea that institutions are breaking down, they're the people are always looking for something to replace that. And I wonder, uh just as of as some food for thought, that as we're s obviously I'm not gonna be in favor of institutional decay, but I do think that as people get frustrated with both parties, I do think they're they are looking for uh something that to fill in that void, right? And they're f looking for, you know, you mentioned the storytelling element, right? You mentioned how um people really do want to find find things that can go beyond those um those things that have historically divided people, right? And there's unfortunately those um same alarmists out there, they're they're trying to divide people, right, into those camps, right? Into the okay, you're you're the pro cutting down every tree in the Sierras kind of person, or or you're you have to be big government, you know, this false dichotomy that they're trying to promote. And so I think there there are these uh these uh very, very insincere and crazy folks out there that are trying to do that. But I do think that the majority of Americans want to feel like they're part of something bigger and part of something that goes beyond uh institutions that have failed us in a lot of ways. Uh, but I hope but hopefully there's something that new that can come out uh that can uh potentially be a benefit there. And um I want to now turn to Hannah. Hannah, I want to talk about the market incentives here. Um this is what's I think is so interesting because um uh I I think there's also a bit of a there's that again that misperception that big arm needs to come in and um and private developers are trying to screw everybody, you know, this like this. Um and and it's like well, I I I think that there's so there's so much about it that irks me because there's it's it's not only disingenuous to uh to paint everyone a broad brush, but I also think that we we have a very uh unique system here where um the free market really has delivered a lot and it's there's there's never a perfect system out there because everyone wants perfect there's perfect that. Uh but I I I feel like the free market is a is a great solution to tackle this. So so tell us about some of those market incentives that Perk is looking at um that is critical for federal state conservation uh and how that all leads into environmental stewardship.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, great question. And I think one of the like the leading pieces here, and Gabriela uh got got at this too, is is the reality that like the results that we are seeing from the current approach aren't aren't working. We're not seeing the conservation that we want to see. We're maybe hearing rhetoric or dollars thrown around. But when we look at an area larger than the state of Nevada has burned in wildfires in the past decade, that's unacceptable. When we look at uh that fewer than three percent or that around right around three percent of species listed under the Endangered Species Act have recovered, that's unacceptable. Like we need to be have holding those conservation values strong, but also truly asking ourselves, is is the rhetoric we're using, are the tools we're using, are are they actually making a difference? And and to the point of where I think we're seeing um this, I'll say reasonable middle continuing to build recognition and to make great strides is because we're sick of those results. We want to see positive outcomes. And that's where a lot of these market incentives have proven themselves so critical and so needed. Um, and that we need to try something else. The the overarching approach of regulate and fully depend on government isn't gonna work. And none of that is against so many of the folks who work on these pieces in government agencies and state agencies and legislative offices, their intentions are really good in most cases, in my experience. However, they lack that full knowledge. It's the classic knowledge problem, right? Where um you you aren't able to understand the full local dynamics, you aren't able to understand the full scientific landscape. And so, in order to get there, you need improved collaboration and you need to get these kind of sticky process procedural barriers out of the way so that that collaboration and local knowledge and exchange can operate effectively. Um so when I think of some of the tools Perks really worked on. Um, one is how do how do we improve the permitting process and get the delays out of the way so that we can do more of that forest restoration? Wildfire is an issue that's near and dear to my heart. I've been evacuated from wildfires. My husband was a wildland firefighter for years. The uh AQI here uh in the West, it was uh, you know, in over 260 in the past weeks. Like that's really bad. That's something that we should all care about. Um, but when we perk dug into this and did research to see, all right, we know that active management and um active forest restoration through tools like prescribed fire and mechanical thinning. So that means clearing out the brush, clearing out dead and decaying fuels, all the things that burn. We have too many things that burn on the ground. And so if we proactively get those out, and that could be through commercial timber harvest, it could be through some innovative approaches uh to biomass or other pieces there, or it could just be saying fires cost us a lot of money, so we're gonna invest in getting this out of the way. We know that when we do those tools, when we apply those treatments on the ground, we can reduce wildfire severity by around up to 70%, which is huge. That's a really big thing. And fire is natural on the landscape, but we're in the age of the mega fire where again things are burning hotter, more intensive, more destructive, and we need to do something about it. The catch is we know what we need to do, but before any drip torch or chainsaw or hiking boot foot can step this, can step on this ground and actually do that work, you have to go through the environmental review process. NEPA, endangered species, that consultation, you know, the whole host of federal acronyms to get something done on the ground. And we looked at that and found that in in many of these cases, and kind of the most stringent environmental review cases, when you go through that review, add litigation on top for some of these frivolous lawsuits, you are looking at well over a decade of delay. Right out my window here in Bozeman, right now, is our watershed, the Bozeman Municipal Watershed, we would be out of water in three days if a fire came through. So this is a really important issue. We knew that we needed the work to get done here, had identified it. Locals, city, uh, water managers, forest service, all these pieces. And we still ended up dragging out that work for well over 15 years. And you know what's crazy is despite all the challenges, all the lawsuits, everything, the project that was finally cleared to move forward was exactly the same as the project was original that was originally proposed. So, as a taxpayer, as a citizen of this community who's dependent on that forest for water, for the wildlife who are dependent on that forest for habitat, we should be really frustrated that that much time, money, and effort was spent dragging out this process that everyone knew was needed and was cleared at the end of the day. So at PERC, uh, that's where a lot of our frustration comes from, is seeing those as the results. And so we say, how can we get how can we remove a lot of these obstacles? So we've explored pieces like categorical exclusions, litigation reform, some of those bigger regulatory pieces in order to allow the process to move forward more naturally. We've also looked more at kind of traditional market incentives. How can we um make it more possible for private for-profit companies to come in and actually do the work to get the clearance to be a partner to do that work and to make money off of the product uh that they remove from the forest? Um, tech and innovation. I know we're gonna talk more about this as we go on. Um, but that's another piece is like how has private industry immersion evolved? Uh a big piece that Perk's pitching right now is this use of virtual fencing. So think of like an electric fence for a dog, right? You can do something really similar with cows. And this is a new technology that's come on, come on uh the market. And I I mean, it's really picked up steam in the past few years. Uh so basically it's a similar concept of your cow wears a collar and it beeps and then it shocks, and the cows are able to understand the lines on the map. Where it's different from maybe a dog approach is instead of having buried um uh like buried transmitters, I guess, you as the as the rancher are able to use technology and use an app to literally and use satellites or towers to literally change um the the virtual fencing for your cows. So you're able to move them more closely. If say there's um an animal died and there's uh predators feeding on the carcass or whatever, you can then you don't even have to go out into the field, you can move your cows away from that hazard uh so that there you're reducing the risk of conflict. Um and I worked on a ranch, I know uh many of us have like fixing barbed wire fence is not a fun job, right? So as we look at uh generational turnover, as we look at efficiency, as we look at costs and all these pieces, there are some really incredible tools and products that the private sector is creating that we can and should be applying to conservation to allow, as Gabrielle is mentioning, that multiple use to continue, those original stewards of the landscape to continue operating on those landscapes while still having that conservation benefit.
SPEAKER_01I'm so glad both of you are not predicting that our world is going to look like the the day after tomorrow, that movie from 2004.
SPEAKER_00Not a chance. We're actually becoming more greener. Um, there's more tree growth, interestingly enough, like there's more species found. So it actually is a positive outlook.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and I I think uh what you talked about, Hannah, with the virtual fencing. This is like the most unscientific uh thing I'm gonna cite today, but I was watching the uh the Clarkson's farm uh featuring Jeremy Clarkson. Oh yes, and uh I think he was using some kind of app or something uh some kind of device to keep the cows there. I mean it's Jeremy Clarkson, so I'm I'm highly doubtful that it really worked out for him. Just like a lot of things on the farm, um, and just a PSA for everybody. I don't think we should be learning farming from Jeremy Clarkson, just out there. Um it seems like a nice guy, nice bloke, but uh it was he you did have some issues there. But I just thought it was interesting how like you you mentioned that, and I was like, oh, I I watched that TV show there, so that's that's pretty cool to kind of keep everybody together. I wish I wish there was something that that we could kind of do uh something virtual to keep our members of Congress and on Capitol Hill so they can get things done instead of always flip fleeing back to their districts all the time um and and uh you know doing doing something else. But uh I I wanted to uh touch upon the innovation part too. Um Hannah, I'll stick with you on this. Uh obviously there's a lot of infrastructure that's involved in that. What what are the kind of barriers to the innovation side that uh is also on the government side that you can touch upon there?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. I I think one of the tools or things that we should be thinking about when when shaping policy is being less prescriptive in what tools we use and more vision casting in what outcomes we want. So an example uh kind of sticking on this grazing piece at Perk uh and as we research it, farmers and ranchers are the original conservationists, right? They are the very core who understands that what you put into the landscape, you're gonna get out. If you uh overuse and destroy the nutrients in the soil and everything this year, you're not gonna get it next year. Like your grass isn't growing, your crops aren't gonna grow, your cows aren't gonna be healthy. So they very intuitively understand that you have to take care of the environment, you have to take care of this natural world because there is this broader connection. Um and so unfortunately, oftentimes what we we have seen kind of in the grazing piece is very prescriptive policy making, such as things of like, all right, well, here's the date that you know your cows can go out on the federal grazing allotment, or here's the tools you have to use, or um, here's what's allowed and what's not allowed, without recognizing like these are the guys on the ground who actually understand that most directly. Uh, and so some tools like the tech innovations like virtual fencing that we've mentioned, right? That's a really great tool where that rancher is going to be the one again to know if there was a predator kill or if there's uh poisonous weeds growing in an area, or if a stream bank's being degraded, and so they need to move the cows to another area. Like they're the ones who know and should have the flexibility to use the tools to adapt to those ever-changing situations on the ground. Um, one positive kind of pilot project that I will highlight uh that that the Trump administration in the first term really helped champion is this concept of outcome-based grazing, where instead of being overly prescriptive as the agency of what exactly needs to happen, they said, like, all right, we want healthy landscapes. Here's the outcome that we want, given kind of where you're at and and the the um natural features and everything. Here's sort of what we want. It's up to you now to manage for that. You are the rancher, you know this landscape, you know your livestock, you know the situation better than ever. And it's rapidly evolving. Nature is ever changing. We need to recognize that. We cannot prescribe what's gonna come. We have to be able to have some flexibility there. Technology is ever changing, right? I mean, think of what AI is even doing for the capacity to process information to be able to adjust the fact that virtual fencing wasn't even an option years back. So it's just even funny small little tweaks of like making sure that language recognizes virtual fencing as a type of fencing, or if a fire uh blows through and um destroys all of the barbari fence, rather than investing in all that physical infrastructure, allow the funds and the grants that would go to fence rebuilding to also go to virtual fencing. So that's my biggest piece with innovation is just um like private sector, private people, local knowledge. We're gonna evolve and adapt and do things better and better and better. What we need are the policies that allow that to function instead of being overly prescriptive in the tools that need to be used.
SPEAKER_01I think it relates very well to how there's a number of people in government that are that don't have the hum the humility to acknowledge that they don't know the area, right? They don't have all the pieces, they don't have all the knowledge. I think it's unfortunate to see some of those policymakers think that they know everything and you know and it's like I don't I've never seen you, I've never seen you standing next to a cow ever, you know. So it's like uh I I think those I think you're absolutely right to bring that local knowledge into within within that policy space. Gabrielle, I'm gonna turn to you and I want to talk about a different part of the world here because I I I know that uh I mean you you talked about your your background there from uh with your family from Lithuania now. I want to talk about an energy crises in Europe because clearly none of us need an air conditioner, right, in the summertime. So um let's look to Europe to should show us how how uh what it's like to to not have air conditioned. I obviously it's uh it's a it's a different world, different political system there, but I'd like to ask you a bit about the the the energy issues that are there and how from this side of the Atlantic, looking at what's happening in Europe, what can those crises teach us about the energy and the free market and just keeping those those principles that we've we've talked about so far?
SPEAKER_00Treating air conditioning as a luxury um could be a problem uh if if such a mindset were to be adopted here in the U.S. And we were actually pretty narrowly close. The Biden admin, uh former Biden Harris administration, was actually looking to regulate uh AC refrigerants and coolants uh in a similar manner. So we we were able to stave off that future at least temporarily. But you look to see what happens there, and and granted, more and more countries in Europe because they're having warmer summers or they're just having to choose to adopt, I would say um the bureaucrats now are having to respond uh and and adjust accordingly, and especially if uh European Union and American relations are being hinged on economic compacts and agreements. I think we'll see a lot of negotiating, perhaps to be like, okay, as part of like working better with us economically, buy more AC technology. I'm surprised that Trump admin hasn't employed that. But yeah, it's kind of become like a cultural lightning rod in Europe when it shouldn't be. And my parents, they didn't really grow up with much of AC, you know, in the Soviet Union. And so for them, living in America for the past 40 years, they're grateful to have that luxury. And I would say it's funny, it's like a weird division. You see, most of this reluctance coming from Western European countries and cities, not so much of a resistance from Central Eastern European countries, countries that had totalitarianism. Funny enough, it's it's not coincidence that there's that there's less of a resistance perhaps to AC. But the problem is it's not just Brussels, it's the individual countries. I was reading through a study from um the CCC. It's not some uh utopian, crazy leftist group, it's a consumer, I forget the name, but a couple of my friends work there. But it's it's a free market group dealing with tech policies, and they did a great study recently, uh, released this year, assessing different countries and what do what does it take. We're talking about programming reform. The the hoops and jumps that Europeans have individual Europeans have to go to to install a basic AC unit in their house. They have to get a slight majority approval from their council if they live in a historic district. They can't just buy an AC unit and then put it into their house. They have to get buy-in from the community, and it takes three months to get approval if you're lucky. And if we had to go through such a patchwork of approval, I mean, it would be a life and death situation. I hate to put it in hyperbolic terms, but we we have seen this summer in in much of Western Europe the unnecessary death of mostly elderly people, 14,000, 15,000, as we're talking. It could be higher after the fact, but there were a lot of unnecessary deaths, heat-related deaths, because of the absence of AC. I think Europe is the only continent to be very reticent to adopt AC. Uh, Asia has it. Singapore credits, for example, one of the most prosperous countries. They credit uh the the modern-day founder who is credited with with really uh catapulting Singapore to success. I can't recall his name off the top of my head. He's slightly long deceased for a while now. Uh, but he credited AC for Singapore's success because if without AC, there wouldn't be this comfortable living standard and people being able to function in such a tropical humid climate such as that in in Singapore. So you see, Africa is adopting this. Much of Asia has AC units, South America has this, but it's been a problem in Europe because they made it a political thing. I would say the French, some Brits, some Berliners, you know, people, like I said, from some of these Western European capitals who just see it as like an American imposition, but it's not an American imposition. And actually, even behind the rhetoric in this anti-AC uh, let's say, um, uh, let's say resistance, you do see the slow adoption of AC units. Like a lot of statistics and data show that by like 2050, a good chunk of Europe will have AC units because it's a it's an adapt or die kind of thing. They recognize that um if they don't have it, they're gonna be uncomfortable. Or you're gonna see. I I think there was a great example in London with um a reality TV host who was uh lambasted by some guy, like, oh, you're being selfish for using AC. And she was like, I have to use it. I have young babies in my house, and the temperature internally was 95 degrees Fahrenheit. I was like, nobody can live comfortably with that. In the United States, that would be unacceptable to let your house warm up to 95 degrees. It would be just ridiculous. We we like to keep our houses cool. Everyone has varying degrees of what that temperature looks like. People sometimes like 62 degrees, some people can tolerate 75, whatever to your liking, as long as you can cool your house and not have, you know, deathly temperatures. Uh, who am I to decide, you know, what's the perfect temperature? But you know, a comfortable, you know, between the high 60s, low 70s, I think is great, personally speaking. But yeah, you see it become political when it shouldn't be. And it goes to this, you know, greater idea that you can protect the environment while also, you know, turning up your AC in the summer. But it's funny, they don't mind heating up their homes in the winter, but they just have this uh hatred of cooling their houses in the summer. But it's just very funny in terms of that. But like I said, it's not all Europeans. I would say it's those kind of more cosmopolitan Europeans who think um, you know, that nobody deserves it. If they can't have it, nobody deserves it. But then you find out actually they're hypocritical and their media outlets have AC units on the top of their buildings, or maybe they have a unit, but they they don't want everyone else to have it. It's it's it's hypocritical. Um, but it goes to it, it fits into this way wider conversation that the reason why you see this uh reluctance to adopt it because they view it as like a detriment to the environment. They say, well, because it's going to emit this much in emissions, it's gonna be bad for the environment. But also they're proposing, uh, but maybe not so much now, but they had been um proposing, you know, get rid of meat consumption in a couple countries. Denmark had put out a blueprint for plant-based diets that should be adopted Europe-wide. Uh, Ireland was set to cull their 300,000 cattle herd numbers. It would have been ridiculous it was stopped, thankfully. Um, so you have kind of seen these extreme policies where you know you think you're doing this for the benefit of the populace, but it actually hurts a lot of people in the process, like Hannah alluded to. The um the uh the conservationists, those closest to the land, who want to make sure that um their uh products and services and their and their operations don't uh lead to a decimation of the environment. Actually, having cows on the landscape, as I've seen in my um reporting work, you need cows because they help keep the environment green. Uh, you don't think of that, but actually, because of their chewing and their presence on the landscape, it helps regenerate. It's very regenerative to have cows on the landscape. And if you replace that with you know factories that produce fake meat, um, you're not gonna get that same effect, that same regeneration that is that is entailed with farming and ranching. Um, so Europe, I think, is gonna be hopefully moving away from this, um, hopefully wanting to reform the process for how you install an AC unit and be like America. And we saw with the World Cup, so many people were coming here from Europe in particular, admiring our conservation practices. They were going to national parks, they were going to hotels with AC, they were going to stadiums that had proper AC ventilation and cooling uh that was happening. They were going to Bass Pro Shop, they were going to, you know, shoot guns and see how um Americans, you know, do that as well. And so I think, you know, social media makes it seem like we're we're divided, that we hate each other. It's not the case. And I think Europeans do appreciate us still as a country and vice versa. I have a lot of friends that live all across Europe, uh, share a lot of the same values like we do in conservation. And so why not, you know, have help bridge the gap? And I think AC can be one way to help bridge this transatlantic tension we might have been facing um recently. And it and it it is a really life-saving measure. And I think more and more Europeans, even in those Western cosmopolitan capitals, are gonna be coming around. It's just a matter of like, are those individual countries and localities gonna deregulate and and have some permitting reform here?
SPEAKER_01For for sure. And um I I I think it's it's again, sponkers. Sponkers what's what happens there. It's a kind of a crazy system uh that they uh they got there. And um and I I've the founders fought for our right to have whatever temperature uh we want to set on our AC. So um and uh I think it's because they didn't have AC at the time uh in the Pennsylvania State House, so in the middle of the summer in Philadelphia, uh which might not have been very comfortable, but they they got it through anyway. Um I I Gary, I think that that's that's that's so important what you talk about with the lessons there from abroad. I just think we we there's a lot that we can learn from other countries, not just what to do, but what not to do. And I think that's a very, very key component here. Uh I want to ask now a big question, really combining a few together, so I'll do my best to do that. Uh I will turn to Hannah, and we we've talked so much about uh these these different pieces, right? Market incentives, about rejecting the the alarmism, about bringing people together, about storytelling, all these things together. Let's uh combine those and kind of how how this all of this can kind of fight two battles at the same time. One is kind of stopping this alarmism, and then two is is strengthening those free market principles. Because I do think that there are times when we we we like to think that we've we have we have the all the free market capitalist kind of uh principles there, but we might not be following them as much as uh as we want to. So what what would you say are are most important things that are happening now that can fight those two battles at the same time, stop that kind of um alarms and that can creep could creep back in any time and to strengthen the free market principles that we we hold dear?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, great question. So as I was thinking about this, uh a piece that I think is really important is how do we, as folks who want to be thinking about and want to see our country continue to move in a way of embracing freedom and sustainability and incentives and local knowledge and all those pieces, we need to be really helping lead in generating ideas on how to do that, right? I think for a very long time, the playbook was all right, if you care about the environment, you propose um a big regulation and a bunch of funding to go with it. And then people who, you know, don't think in that same way would would fight it. And you'd see all of these just like coalition letters going back and forth getting sent to committees or agencies or public comments or testimonies where one group would be like, well, the solution is we need more money and more control. And the other group would say, like, no, we don't, that's bad for everything. But what we've kind of been missing, um, but I think is starting to emerge, and I'd encourage us all to like really embrace is coming up with what are the alternative ideas, like what are the pieces that are good for conservation and the positive ideas that people want to champion, that people want to back, and that people want to get like be working on with each other. Um, that I think is a huge tactic. Um, because that's it's I would say um in my work in government affairs, I oftentimes say it's like it's easier to kill a bill. It's easier to get an appropriations writer. What's hard is getting an idea in a piece of legislation and through the process. It's hard. There's a reason that hasn't been the playbook for a long time. But that's what's needed. And I think that's what gets people excited is an idea to convene around and to actually make that happen. Um, and maybe an example I'll throw out there is a lot of this forest work that is clearly so near and dear to my heart, a lot of these reforms, for so long the issue was like, well, either you need uh to let timber companies come in and cut down more trees, or we just need um, you know, an unlimited blank check for the government to do these things. I think what we found out is that like neither is really the solution. Um, but what's been really amazing, a piece of legislation I'll throw out there that I know Gabrielle has been following as well, is the Fix Our Forest Act. Um and I'm so hopeful that this can get across the finish line, this Congress. But it has been amazing to see this incredible bipartisan effort emerge where folks, uh both from the stakeholders but also the actual like members of Congress who are engaging on this, had some questions up front. They were maybe unsure about uh like how's litigation reform gonna work here, or do we really need this research here? But being able to come together and say, like, all right, we've dug in on the ideas. Perk and many others um have helped champion those ideas and done the hard work of communicating why those ideas matter. To Gabriela's point on the storytelling, on the communicating complicated research in a way that's approachable and tangible and relevant. Like that work had to be done. But now there are positive ideas that people are convening around. And I think that's gonna be the biggest uh challenge and motivator and ultimately opportunity for those of us who want to think about conservation in this more free market way is to find those ideas and make the case of why they work for conservation and why we need the results. And the current approach just isn't cutting it.
SPEAKER_01And same question, real quick, to Gabriella. Uh, just anything you want to add to what Hannah said.
SPEAKER_00I concur with what Hannah said, and I think you can equip yourselves with, you know, different tools, policymaking. We do a lot of that actually, independent women as well. Um at the state side, uh, federal government, we engage in a lot of rulemaking as well. And it's you I think you combine, you know, um, the the input of the private sector. I I talk to people from the private sector, I have board advisors for my center. I to I try to, you know, stay humble and and informed by talking to people on the ground where I can't be on the ground. I have lots of friends spread out all across the country, people I've interviewed, people I've worked with to be better informed. And I think listening to those who have to deal with this directly is extremely important. And and hearing what they have to say and what they convey uh could help inform you better when you're trying to help influence and policy make in this space. And I think Hannah's right, innovation, AI, we we keep talking about data centers, artificial intelligence. I think those tools are often being built as an impediment to human function or to human productivity. But I think, you know, we we still are going to be arbiters of any of these tools that come around. And if it if they can be used to make our lives easier, to help make conservation a more viable end goal, I think that's what you have to look at it, you know, in that respect and and and not kind of view things with, you know, this antagonistic lens. You know, whatever tools you can have at your disposal, whether it's deregulation, some AI semblance, uh, private sector involvement, have every tool at your disposal. And what do you have to lose when it comes to conservation gains and conservation wins and victories? I think that's we have to look at things, you know, in this way versus this kind of subtraction notion of and and having to subtract and and leaning too much on government because in the future we could have you know an all-powerful government and these problems persist. And I think people want to move away from that paradigm and to something that is reasonable and possible. And so I think, you know, looking to all the tools at your disposal is extremely important. So I don't want to take away from Hannah said, but but echo and add a little bit more to that because I thought that was important. But that's kind of my view of it too, because we we're, you know, going into the future, you have to be creative, you have to be innovative, perhaps irreverent if you want to see some sort of meaningful change. And that doesn't mean you have to upend what we appreciate, what we value uh in and in the landscapes um that we enjoy. I think you know, we can work in concert with the new tools that we have at our disposal.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. If sorry, one more thing I just want to add on this, um, because it's it's it's a challenge. Is like I think many of us with our our frame of thinking, right? You have your ideal of where do you want to get to? Um, like what's your end goalpost? Uh, but I think especially with conservation, we really need to celebrate moving the needle and focus on moving the needle as well. Um, I think uh, I know you guys met at Freedom Fest. I'm a part of, you know, the same kind of free market think tank world, right? Where so many of us kind of have these ideals of how the world should be. And that's amazing. Um, but I think we also need to start from like, where are we at currently and not let the perfect be the enemy of the good, right? Of understanding we need to focus on progress, not perfection. Um, and that's where I think we're able to kind of maybe incrementally make those changes to get policymakers, agency folks, uh, locals on the ground, conservation groups, other think tanks, all those pieces. Like we need to, we need to focus on some of that incremental stuff. Not lose sight of the big picture by any means. Uh, but remember that incremental progress is also a really, really good thing and deserves being celebrated instead of just constantly comparing ourselves to where do we fall short from the the total end goal and instead say, great, we made a really positive step. How do we keep taking steps?
SPEAKER_01That's right. Be be on offense. Uh that's that's the number one thing I get from sports. Uh if I don't say that my my school's former coach, Nick.
SPEAKER_02Pick up yards when you can, because like very rarely do you get the Hail Mary touchdown pass. Like you gotta you gotta keep chipping away and and making really incremental, good, meaningful progress.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. I love the football enthusiasm as football season is is uh up and running. Um well, I want to uh now ask a final question. I'll start with Hannah and then with Gabriella here. Uh the first is that we reflect on Washington's farewell address, reflecting on values like patriotism, faith, national unity, education, fiscal responsibility, and civility. Um so that's the first part, just what sticks out to you from those, and then uh how can people learn more about your work? Because obviously we've had such a wonderful conversation. This past hour just flew by. And uh, I want to give you each of you an opportunity to share about your organization, just how people can learn more about what you're doing. So, Hannah, I'll start with you.
SPEAKER_02Awesome. Uh, I I so appreciate you bringing up Washington's Fareball Address because with it being, you know, Freedom 250 and the America's 250th anniversary, I've been thinking a lot about patriotism and especially patriotism of place, right? Of the pride that we have, um, whether you're looking out over the Florida Everglades or the coast or uh, you know, beautiful prairie ranch lands here in Montana or whatever it might be. Like we have this immense pride in our country and these incredibly diverse and valued landscapes where none is exactly the same, and all of them contribute so much to this American heritage and all these pieces that we so fiercely defend and love. And so I I think that that that tool of just that kind of that patriotism of place is so essential in a lot of that and is such a motivator for people to get involved in things and why people care so much and why why ultimately I kind of think the environment in in comparison to so many other issues is such an emotional issue. Um, and it's because we do truly have that patriotism of place. So, as Gabrielle mentioned, we actually just put out um a report on America's 250th and uh and some of the ideas and conservation values of looking back and looking forward to that next era of conservation, which leads very nicely to how you can stay in touch with Perk or if you want to check out that issue of our Perk Reports magazine. Just go to our website, PERC.org. Uh, you can sign up for our free magazines, uh, get our newsletters, or just putz around and see whatever interests you. Um, and I'm always open to talk about things. Please feel free to reach out to me directly. Again, my my email and contact information is all on the website.
SPEAKER_01Excellent. Uh Gabriella, uh, you'll have the last word.
SPEAKER_00Conservation is part of our birthright. And I think all of the themes that were touched in George Washington's farewell address can can epitomize that. Um, when you think of conservation, it touches on so many different things. Uh, and I I come to you actually from a not too far from his Mount Vernon estate, and you go there and you see, you know, that he was a fisherman, that he maintained his grounds, he cared about conservation. You see that before or around his time, you had timber wolves living in this region. It's it's unbelievable, you know, what happened. And you kind of take away lessons from the colonial times, from our origins, and and what we can do better. And like I mentioned earlier, we had made some mistakes, you know, in conservation in the past, but we have really charted into this positive direction with people evolving and and different reforms coming about. And I think that's what you can channel into 250, where you don't have to trade economic productivity for conservation of the environment. And you could look to founding fathers and our first president, like George Washington, like I said, who I live whose estate is pretty close to my house, and appreciate, you know, the the principles and foundation that he laid for this type of work and for these values. So I think it's extremely important. And we try to channel these nuanced perspectives, uh, going back to how you can connect with us at our Center for Energy and Conservation. Uh, you can find all of our work classes. There are lots of reports, um, interesting, tie-in into cultural issues. We talk about AC a lot too, um, what's happening in Europe as it relates to United States policy, um, conservation, and the like. And I'm pretty visible on social media, very approachable. So if anyone has any questions about conservation, energy questions, more than happy to be a resource.
SPEAKER_01Amen to both of you. Anything to do to make Smokey the Bear happy is what we're what we're all about. Uh Gabrielle and Hannah, thank you so much for coming on a podcast today.
SPEAKER_02Awesome. Thank you so much, Jim, for having us. It was it was an honor. A pleasure and an honor. Good to catch up.
SPEAKER_00Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Thank you all so much for listening to this episode. Don't forget, we have new episodes on the first two Mondays of every month. One interview and one solo show, and we've got bonus episodes throughout the year. So if you enjoyed this podcast, subscribe and share, friends and fellow citizens with your friends and family. Enjoy the rest of your day. And remember, a day in America is always better. We're with our friends.