Friends & Fellow Citizens
In this unique civics podcast, discover how the principles of George Washington's Farewell Address (patriotism, civility, faith, education, national unity, and fiscal responsibility) apply to today! With a focus on American political institutions and policymaking, hear fascinating stories and discussions that any America-loving listener can enjoy!
This non-partisan podcast is a remarkable mix of solo shows, interviews and special guests that gives you a great boost of freedom! New episodes on the first two Mondays of each month!
Friends & Fellow Citizens
#195: Washington's BD Ep. - Theodore Roosevelt's Vast Frontiers of Governance and Natural Preservation feat. Dr. Michael Cullinane
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
With multiple favorite U.S. presidents to choose from, few if any stand out like Theodore Roosevelt. What made the 26th POTUS uniquely interested in nature? How will North Dakota play an important role later in July 2026 to finally preserve his legacy?
Dr. Michael Patrick Cullinane, Chair of Roosevelt Studies at Dickinson State University and Public Historian at the Theodore Roosevelt Association, shares the inspirations and contributions of the Rough Rider who brought the U.S. to a new century of conservation and diplomacy.
Check out Mike's website and learn more about the Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library on its website!
Visit georgewashingtoninstitute.org to sign up for our e-mail list! The site is the one-stop shop of all things Friends & Fellow Citizens and George Washington Institute!
JOIN as a Patreon supporter and receive a FREE Friends & Fellow Citizens mug at the $25 membership level!
IMPORTANT NOTE/DISCLAIMER: All views expressed by the host are presented in his personal capacity and do not officially represent the views of any affiliated organizations. All views presented by guests are solely those of the interviewees themselves and may or may not represent the views of their affiliated organizations, the host, Friends & Fellow Citizens, and/or The George Washington Institute.
If there's any job that the president has, it's being in charge of that huge bureaucratic system. Roosevelt completely transforms the State Department in this time, too. So he creates well, during during his time, he was basically creating the very first bureaus, geographical bureaus within the State Department, and putting in place experts that are going to lead in those areas. All of those are established under him. So the first people that are studying language, the first foreign service officers that are going to be, you know, fully fully paid, and not, you know, not just rich uh patricians who are you know are paying for a pink tea party overseas. This was the professionalization of American diplomacy.
SPEAKER_01Patriotism, faith, national unity, education, fiscal responsibility, civility, the values that define America. Fascinating stories and talks from America-loving patriots dedicated to preserving freedom, opportunity, and justice. Welcome to the Friends and Fellow Citizens Podcast. Thank you all so much for joining me for this bonus interview episode. Happy President's Day 2026. I hope you are enjoying the long weekend. If you're listening beyond Presidents' Day, Happy President's Day anyway, because maybe every day is a former President's Day for all of us. Before we get started, I want to first welcome to all those who are joining us for the very first time. Welcome to the program. We got some great content that we have recorded and we've got some great content coming up. So if you haven't already, make sure to subscribe to our podcast, subscribe to your favorite podcast app, or subscribe on YouTube. We got some new video episodes coming out. You don't want to miss those. So don't forget to subscribe. Subscribe to our podcast. Also, as always, a big shout out and thank you to our dedicated Patreon supporters. They are the most dedicated fans forward to this show. They're helping to keep this show uh running smoothly, but also just uh for their generosity, it's such a big deal for all of us. So uh please uh rec help me recognize these folks. Uh, if you're enjoying our content, would like to be part of this effort, part of something bigger, part of our our community here, be sure to check our Patreon page and become a Patreon member today. Uh, we got some great merch. We have our podcast mugs, which are a fan favorite and guest favorite. And so definitely check those out uh down in the show notes below. Well, without further ado, I'd like to welcome our special guest, Dr. Michael Patrick Culinane from Dickinson State University. Mike, thank you so much for coming on our podcast today.
SPEAKER_00Oh, it's a pleasure to be here. Thanks for having me, Sherman.
SPEAKER_01Well, I am just so excited to talk about one of the great presidents in American history. And it is uh, first of all, very very surprising to see that when we think of Rosewell, we might think of New York, because I mean FR is already there. But obviously what Dickinson State University is in Dickinson, North Dakota, which we'll talk a bit about that connection between North Dakota and and the Theodore Roosevelt, uh, who is our president we're to discussing today. So to commemorate our president's day, I'd like to always get into a topic of uh everything about presidents, but particularly for this one here. And so uh before we get to our main conversation, Mike, can you just tell us a bit about yourself and why Theodore Roosevelt for you?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, good question. So uh I am originally from New Jersey, and uh I have always had a fascination with the presidency as well. I think that dates back to my grandfather's love for uh Franklin Roosevelt and Ronald Reagan, actually. And he never found anything uh strange about voting for a Democrat and Republican in his lifetime, or you know, he was just voting for two men that he thought were the the best, you know, the best people for that job. And that always that always interested me. And then when I went and decided to do a PhD like you're doing, uh, and I I wanted to research this is in the midst of the Iraq war in 2003, 2006, when the surge happened, I started my my PhD, and um I wanted to study the anti-imperialist movement, which was the anti-war movement from TR's time. And of course, TR is the antagonist in that story. He's not, you know, the he doesn't agree with a lot of the anti-imperialists, but they're still able to break bread and they're still able to come together and be friends, really. And uh that I thought was pretty remarkable because it's so different from our current situation, political situation, where things seem so divisive sometimes that uh, you know, being a friend with Democrats or Republicans, you know, that that can be difficult for some people. So anyway, I wanted to study TR at that point because he just seemed such a larger-than-life character, but I didn't want to write another biography because there are like 400 or 500 biographies of Theodore Roosevelt. So I wrote a posthumous biography of Theodore Roosevelt. It was about what happened to his legacy and how he was used and abused by successive generations of Americans over the years.
SPEAKER_01Fascinating. I mean, I I I thought there was gonna be a teddy bear in that story, but um it's uh um I I was uh I I like what you said there about legacy because uh I think, as you said, it's one thing to read about a biography, and I and don't get me wrong, biographies are great, uh, depend depending on which biographer. There's some are great, not so great. But for you to focus a bit on the legacy there, I think that's what's particularly interesting because we'll never live the Teddy Roosevelt era, but we're always going to be thinking about Theodore Roosevelt and not every president. And so it's so important to have good scholars like you to be at the forefront here. And uh I I I want to get into a bit about the Theodore Roosevelt. I guess we'll start at kind of his early life here, uh, Mike, because uh I I I I think they're just knowing who Teddy Roosevelt became later on, uh it's it's wonderful to see how someone can be in all these different roles. It just seems like you can't really place, other than president, you can't really place a label on him just because he did so many things. But uh, what can you just share about some of the unique early qualities that Roosevelt had in terms of his ability to lead and and just some of the things that early in on his life that you think affected his trajectory and his career later on?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a that's a very lengthy answer I can probably give you on that. I mean, that's that's probably a dissertation in itself. But let me let me just say to your point about you know him being the the president and and that being the reason why we're talking about him today, interestingly enough, there are fewer biographies written about Theodore Roosevelt's presidency than any other aspect of his life. And I think as you pointed out uh quite nicely there, there's so many facets to this man's life. And if we go back to his youth and his upbringing in New York City, which you know, outside of Donald Trump, he's the only president to come from New York City. He has a really privileged background, his parents are very wealthy, his whole family is exceedingly wealthy. They're the Knickerbockers, so they have Dutch heritage um dating back to the 16th century in um in New York. And uh, and yeah, so he he he lives he lives this sort of rarefied upbringing, but because he's sick as a kid, he suffers from asthma, he's really um he's really quite sheltered in his early years. So he's kept in his room quite a bit, which is actually where his love of nature comes from. Like the inability to go out into the world is the thing that makes him want to get out in the world. Um, and uh, and so yeah, he he sort of he he stumbles upon uh a seal carcass in Manhattan one day, and that really just inspires him to to know everything he can about nature. So he starts learning like the taxonomies of genus and species, and he he starts shooting birds, and he, you know, he he falls in love with nature and natural history, and um, and that that's that's you know only one aspect of that that part of his life. I mean, as a as a young boy as well, you know, I know we'll talk about conservation, but like it didn't just come from his love of the outdoors, it came, I think, from his uncle as well, who we we often don't talk about, Robert Barnwell Roosevelt, who was his next door neighbor. And he was a really remarkable character in his own right. He was the man who's responsible for the New York uh Fish and Game Commission. He's responsible for the U.S. uh Fish Commission, the national body that looks after fish and game. And uh and he was the one who came up, well, he in part came up with the idea of fair chase and sports hunting. So this was a man that was opposed to what was happening to nature in America during this industrial revolution, which was the wholesale slaughter of species. I mean, the buffalo, as we know, TR is gonna shoot, uh, but he knows it's he he wants to shoot it because he knows it's gonna be gone soon. Um and and and and there's an irony in all of that, which I can explain further, but his upbringing is one that is is both, you know, this sort of rarefied patrician family background, but one that is because of that perhaps uh also one that is yearning to be in nature and to uh and and and and to find out more about the natural world.
SPEAKER_01Uh I'd love to ask you about that irony. I think I was thinking in terms of to if I can put on my social scientist hat for a second, you know, one of the debates in social science is how much the human world is similar or different compared to the the natural world, you know, and this is this kind of uh if you talk about positivism versus interpretivism. And I I was I was thinking of, you know, it could be that with someone like him, you know, looking at how animals behave, looking at how humans interact with nature, I mean that that seems like a whole other dimension of smarts that you can gain uh just by observing and just by observing nature. And uh I I'm I'm wondering, I I'm not s saying maybe you should have been pushed to do a PhD in political science uh at that point. But uh I I think that's just so interesting to know that someone like him was that observant and and could have that interest that carried him into his presidency, which we'll talk about later. Uh uh Mike, and can you get a bit more into that irony that you were talking about earlier? Because uh I I think it'll be interesting, particularly as we see how his presidency plays out uh when we talk about it, and just how just how those elements influenced his upbringing and and later on his development there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, if we're talking about conservation, some of America's foremost conservationists are also hunters. Um, you know, I've I've heard uh a lot said about Steve Ranella recently, you know, he's the podcaster and the writer, um, and he's also probably one of America's foremost sportsmen right now. But he's talked about Theodore Roosevelt and this um irony of conservation and then hunting, you know, about how those two worlds come together. And it might not seem like they do, but if you don't conserve wildlife and the natural environment or habitats that wildlife um avail of, then you won't be able to hunt them because they'll be gone. And Theodore Roosevelt very much thought this. But in the moment, when you think about killing something that is potentially extinct, it does seem like uh something that is so ironic that it doesn't make any sense whatsoever. Let me give you an example. Roosevelt would shoot a white rhino, he would shoot two white rhinos in Africa, and just before he shot that white rhino, he said, well, this might be the last white rhino on earth. And then he shot it anyway. Um, and the purpose of that was to bring it back to put it in the Smithsonian so that we could study it. And interestingly enough, today they are repopulating the white rhinos in Uganda, where Roosevelt shot two of them. They're repopulating them on the basis of all of the collections that Roosevelt saved back in 1910. So he gave all those collections thousands and thousands, I think the order of like 12,000 specimens taken. And those rodents, those birds, those insects, those fish that were taken from that expedition in 1910, are informing scientists today on how to repopulate that area with white rhinos. So it's a remarkable thing to think that killing something might just preserve it. But if you talk to folks that are duck hunters, like the folks of Ducks Unlimited or other, you know, conservation bodies like the Boone and Crocket Club, which Theodore Roosevelt himself founded in the 1890s, that is exactly what they say. They say that sportsmen, their license fees, their their activism is what is saving these species from extinction.
SPEAKER_01It's so it's so fascinating when you see these episodes of history where someone is taking that leap to to conserve. And that does seem like the just the general theme of Theodore Roosevelt, conserve conserve in a lot of different ways, right? Almost like whether it's consumer protection, conserving the consumer, or conserving the environment, or uh conserving national security, or what it would be national security later on. I mean, uh there's there's so many, so many different elements there. So I'm I'm I'm starting to think that he truly is the conservationist, uh not just in the environmental sense, but I think then in other aspects of his life. Uh Michael, uh in terms of just uh I would like to situate uh Roosevelt within this larger conservation movement, if I may, um, in terms in this time period in the late 1800s, early 1900s, how did and how unique was he in in this interest in conservation? You know, was I mean I'm thinking of other figures like for example John Muir around that time. But uh was in terms of someone with that kind of stature and politically, socially, um, was this relatively new or was this already of a trend that was occurring uh uh over the years?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a great question because it it's both of those things. Uh Roosevelt was a trailblazer and he was part of a wider context of conservation. So if you look, I mean I mean I mentioned the Boone and Crockett Club. If if you if you look at what's going on around the Boone and Crockett Club, right? So this is a group that's uh hunters that are looking to conserve wildlife around the country. Um, but there are other groups that are forming at this time as well. So the there's the Audubon Society, which it's it's first founded in in New York, and uh and that's only a few years, maybe one or two years before or after the Boone and Crockett Club. Um, there is the Sierra Club, which is founded in the 1890s, and that that, of course, is a wildlife and and park preservation society. That's John Muir, of course, who's the leader of that group. But there are there are so many other things that are going on in the world of environmental conservation at this time. You've got the universities that really uh not until Darwin's theory of evolution and the origin of species is published in the 1850s, they don't really start putting on courses about zoology or um or ornithology until the 1860s. So that's all part and parcel of this too. And then you also have the movement to conserve uh the trees, which is really led in part by uh one of Roosevelt's closest friends and a fellow New Yorker, uh Gifford Pinchot, who is going to be the chief forester during Roosevelt's time. But he also would have been trying to bring the ideas that are developing in Europe around forest preservation to America, including, you know, in a higher education, bringing forestry into places like Yale, which that was the first place that had a forestry course on. So this is, you know, this is a this a broad movement across all parts of environmental conservation. It's birds and it's irrigation, reclamation, it's parks preservation. And of course, all of these Roosevelt would have a hand in when he's president. So when he's president, we often refer to the number of acres that he protected, which included national forests, the first ever bird reserves. I mean, that's that's a first. Uh, he wasn't the first to do national parks, but he did preserve several national parks. Uh, reclamation, I mean, there's a huge amount of land in the West that owes its existence to Roosevelt, whether we're talking about cities like Phoenix or or elsewhere. And then, and then, of course, there's even things like coal reserves that Theodore Roosevelt put aside to be measured and then to be used appropriately as a natural resource. So it's it's to the order of 230 million acres, which is really a staggering figure for any president. And other presidents after Roosevelt would rely on his um on his precedents and you know his executive orders to make those like his cousin Franklin Roosevelt, like doubles the size of many of Roosevelt's of Theodore Roosevelt's um uh national forests or parks and that sort of thing. So um it's really an important moment in the nation's history around environmental protection.
SPEAKER_01Wild. I mean, there's the fact that one president, I mean, this really goes a bit into the theme of president say, which is this idea of setting norms and setting the precedent. And uh we all we don't often think about that at the at the moment in times when people are so focused on that next political move or just within the moment of politics. But when we step back and we look and see uh just how much precedent plays a role and how much norms play a role, I I I guess Theodore Roosevelt seems like he's he's really set that environmental norm for the presidency, and maybe for for Congress too, because it's of course uh having some back in Congress is kind of a big deal for for any president as as much as the president can. Uh I I just again uh appreciate what you what you said there about the the the acreage, right? And then just this the normity uh of uh not to mention we didn't have we still we still had a few states that hadn't entered the union yet and also you know that's still that's still that's a big that's a really big deal. Uh I want to step back, Mike, if I can, just on his rise to the presidency, because obviously he his ascendance to the presidency is is not a very happy one because uh we, of course, had elected William McKinley in 1896, and unfortunately he's assassinated uh in New York. And uh can you what can you tell us about the moment uh that Theodore Roosevelt realizes that he, as the vice president, he's taking over as president, and just like the enormity of the responsibility um uh that that he had to take on when he became president in the wake of a national tragedy like that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's I think the best way to describe it is frantic. And I don't mean that because of Theodore Roosevelt's mindset, I mean it because of the the situation that he finds himself in. So, of course, McKinley is shot in Buffalo. He does not die right away, and and so there's a uh a period between the assassination attempt and uh the time when McKinley eventually succumbs to the the bullet uh wound. And in that in that period, Roosevelt does show up in Buffalo to to kind of see if he's needed and and to be a good vice president and you know and and kind of help out. But he realizes that when he gets there, that his presence might make some people uncomfortable, that he's almost seeking the the presidency off the the back of the misfortune of McKinley. And so he leaves rather abruptly, and he his his kids and his wife are on holiday in the Adirondacks in New York, which isn't too far from Buffalo. He hops out of the train and goes to uh the Adirondack's to climb Mount Marcy, which is the large largest peak in in New York. And it's Wally's pretty much atop Mount Marcy. There's a small lake about uh a few hundred miles from the the peak called Lake Tier of the Clouds, and he's up there coming down when a messenger meets him to let him know that the president is going to die and that he needs to get to he needs to get back to Buffalo. And it's a long journey. So he he comes down off the mountain and goes to a sporting club and he has dinner there. And by the by that evening, about 10 o'clock, he leaves to get to North Creek train station, which is the nearest train station that'll take him to Buffalo. There's a special car that's been put on and all that. And uh it takes him oh, 10 hours or so to go less than 10 miles, really, uh, maybe, maybe 20 miles from the sporting club to the North Creek train station. And he it's actually three three coaches he has to take, three different drivers. It's a frantic ride on these corduroy roads, muddy and and you know, at any stage, if you know, if there was an accident, I don't know what the nation would be doing. But he finally gets to North Creek Station, and uh just before he gets there, he hops off of the coach and he straightens his tie and he dusts off his clothes, and then he prepares himself to get back to Buffalo. And when he does, he he goes to uh a friend, a friend of his house and uh he takes the oath of office and becomes president. So that's why I say it's it's kind of a frantic moment. He did say that when it was a dreadful way to come to the presidency, but that he didn't want to be morbid about it. It and he he knew that there was a job to do. He keeps almost all of McKinley's cabinet for at least the first year or so, and then some people resign and some people are reappointed and things are shuffled around. But it was a fairly morbid way to come to the presidency.
SPEAKER_01Wow. Of course, Lincoln before that. So it seemed like not to say that he should have been prepared, obviously, because who can ever prepare for something like that? But just the fact that it was happening every 15 years or so, uh, 15-20 years, that that that's gotta be pretty uh unnerving just as in terms of the role of the vice president there, you know.
SPEAKER_00Um strangely enough, Sherman, uh John Hay, who is Theodore Roosevelt's Secretary of State, had been there for McKinley's death, for Garfield's death, and he was the secretary for Abraham Lincoln as well. So he had seen all three of those presidents die.
SPEAKER_01Wow. Wow, well, uh I can't even imagine that. I mean, I wow. I mean, that's talk about somebody who's gone through a lot. I mean, seeing you imagine uh the conversation between him and and Theodore Roosevelt and uh just the realization that that someone that the particularly when we're talking about presidents are reflecting on the hard job of a president, knowing that uh the responsibilities all can just shift so quickly um to the next person who has to keep keep that office going, right? And um wow, that's I I can't imagine that I did not know that, Mike.
SPEAKER_00Uh that's uh I'll I'll have to look I'll have to look him up and see see what kind of career he had probably he um he lived to tell apparently um through through all the remarkable career and when he does um when Roosevelt does get inaugurated in 1905 after winning the 1904 election, John Hay, one of the last things he does, because he dies uh only shortly thereafter, he gives Roosevelt a ring with a piece of uh one single piece of hair from Abraham Lincoln's head. And uh this is uh a gift, you know, Roosevelt deeply admired Abraham Lincoln for so many reasons, but not least because of his management of the Civil War and his promotion of the Reconstruction Constitution. And uh and that that would that would guide TR. Like it was almost like a symbol or an emblem of uh that tradition, that Republican tradition that he so admired from Lincoln.
SPEAKER_01Wow. That's that's so touching. I mean, uh when let's kind of move to that part there in terms of just taking on the mantle of the presidency. You know, his um he assumes office and all. And uh uh uh something that that uh gonna made me just just think in terms of the reflecting on Lincoln as an example is uh just knowing that he's taking on not just a new a new job, a new I mean I I don't think I I don't think it's just a it's it's not just any job, it's a whole other element of responsibility. It's hard to even describe the presidency as a job. But he's also assuming this new, literally this new century. Um he's also assuming uh this new era of the United States in terms of its place in the world, because we had the Spanish-American War uh and the uh not not just the not just what happened with the conflict, but the fact of how it happened, where uh you had basically newspapers with yellow journalism uh are all around, uh put basically pushing the United States into this new territory of of involvement in international affairs and with this major conflict. And so uh Mike, I'd like to just ask, in terms of if I could shift to foreign policy, we'll get back to conservation a little later, but in terms of foreign policy, he doesn't just find himself in this new position, he finds the U.S. in this new century here. Uh what can you tell us about how Theodore Roosevelt was processing, thinking about the U.S. foreign policy in this day and age, now that or in that day and age, uh as he's assuming a new role, as he's still figuring things out, and he too also has his own views on the U.S. involvement in uh wars and conflict and whatnot.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so Theodore Roosevelt saw himself as a jingo. He called himself that, which is, you know, his his sense was that uh America's interests are everywhere, they're not just limited to the continent. Um, and then he was, you know, you mentioned the Spanish-American War. He was not just an outspoken uh advocate of American intervention in Cuba, but he went and fought in Cuba. I mean, that's what sort of made TR uh a household name was the charge up San Juan Heights with the Rough Riders. So he's not just an advocate of American um involvement in global affairs, he is the embodiment of that since 1898. And before he's president, he he he talks very much about the Monroe Doctrine being important, but he also speaks very much about, well, I mean, famously, right, there's the big stick, right? Which is speak softly and carry a big stick. We often think about TR wielding the big stick in places like Panama or Santo Domingo, or even in Morocco, and he threatened to use American military to end a dispute there. But what we what we fail, if we just look at the big stick on its own, we fail to realize that Theodore Roosevelt is probably one of the most important diplomats of this period. I mean, not just because of um his place as president and his belief in the importance of America being involved in global affairs, but his work in arbitration. So obviously, we we know that he's going to mediate the Russo-Japanese War and he'll win the peace prize for that, the Nobel Peace Prize. But he was also such a strong advocate of arbitration that he he uses it to settle a dispute in Venezuela. He uses it to settle a dispute in Morocco, which kind of forestalled World War I in many respects. He set up arbitration treaties with Great Britain and France. You know, he saw this as the mechanism by which international disputes could be solved, not the big stick. The speak softly part was much more important to Theodore Roosevelt. And also he would have been a major advocate of international law, the international court of um of justice, and he he will support uh the negotiations that go on in The Hague for to establish those things. So he is very much an internationalist in this sort of liberal internationalist sense of that word. Um he is not an America first president, he is he is an outspoken internationalist. But with that said, there are some places where he does not um he does use the big stick. I think Panama is probably the best example of that. So a revolution between Panamanians and the Colombians, the Columbia, Panama was part of Colombia, it was a state in Colombia. And uh when that revolution breaks out uh against the backdrop of the Colombians wanting more money for a lease and the land to build a canal there, Roosevelt supports the revolutionaries by sending a gunboat down. I mean, it's you know, it is kind of imperial gunboat diplomacy. Um, and they they eventually negotiate a treaty that gives the United States a 100-year lease on a 10-mile strip of land that they build the canal on. So um there are times that he uses the big stick when it's um expedient for American interests, I think. And that's that's worth pointing out as well. But the the main thing to take away is that Roosevelt is probably the first president to understand America's uh modern place in the world. Like before his cousin Franklin Roosevelt would create this new international order after World War II. Roosevelt had started that really before even World War I had happened. Um and so he's a really important figure for that reason. The American century, in my mind, always began in Theodore Roosevelt's presidency before uh you know Luce declared it in in 1945.
SPEAKER_01Well said. I I like what you said about the two components there with the first part of the there's probably a reason why he's he didn't say carry a big stick and then speak softly. I I think it would have I think people would have been a bit confused about that. Uh but it's the fact that I think as you said, right when when you you do engage in that diplomatic channel, when you start conversations, as I imagine that he with his upbringing on, I'm sure he understood the power of conversation, of spending quality time understanding uh how people resolve disputes and conflict.
SPEAKER_00And uh let me say one more thing, Sharon, that's a bit boring here that I I know most people won't appreciate, but I have a feeling you will, because in this sort of long the longitudinal view of the presidency, it is a the boss of the bureaucracy. I mean, if it's if if there's any job that the president has, it's being in charge of that huge bureaucratic system. Roosevelt completely transforms the State Department in this time, too. So he creates well, during his time, he was basically creating the very first bureaus, geographical bureaus within the State Department, and putting in place experts that are going to lead in those areas. So we don't have people like uh William Phillips or George Kennan later on just because you know it was expedient to have their opinions. We have their opinions. We have the long telegram, we have all of the diplomacy of the State Department because we have Theodore Roosevelt there setting up the divisions of Far Eastern Affairs or Latin American affairs or you know the Near East, all of those are established under him. So the first people that are studying language, the first Foreign Service officers that are going to be, you know, fully fully paid and not, you know, not just rich uh patricians who are you know are paying for a pink tea party overseas. This was the professionalization of American diplomacy.
SPEAKER_01Interesting. So it it does seem like with the when we think about just going back to the role of the president, think about the just then the number of hats that the president would have to wear. And it seems like there's there's the the presence that we've recognized in the in the past, they created those new hats in a way, right? This new hat of bureaucratic management. You think about just nowadays, with uh how large the country has become over the years and how many more responsibilities government has had to take on, you know, what what does that new Theodore Roosevelt like minded uh minded presidency look like in terms or presidency mindset that it will take to reimagine bureaucracy and to reimagine the uh the purpose of government? Uh just some questions for people to think about, because there truly just so many things that we we demand the president of, right? We demand that the president is a great campaigner and a great policymaker, a great uh uh uh a great person that Congress would love to work with, uh a great uh great statesman, right? There's so many of these expectations that we we hold for the presidency. And for Roosevelt to to have set so many of those norms, uh given that you he was still learning on the on the job and learn and learning, I guess you can never, as a president, you can never say that you've fully learned everything about the presidency. I guess in a way how Washington, when he wrote the farewell address, kind of indicated that I didn't get everything right and that there's always a new side of the presidency that you learn over time, and the only way you can really experience it is to become president.
SPEAKER_00Um Yeah, that's a great point. I mean, the farewell address, I know that's something that we might talk about at some stage, but TR uh did subscribe to the idea of uh, you know, not getting too involved with entangling alliances. The only other thing I'd say about him and his foreign policy is that he's very much a nationalist as well as an internationalist. So that's quite a complicated thing to say, I think, but it that really plays out in the post-war negotiations at the treaty uh at Versailles, um, you know, with the eventual treaty that would come from that. He distinguished his foreign policy from Woodrow Wilson very much on the basis that the League of Nations put the community of nations first, that all nations were equal. And Roosevelt believed that there was a fallacy at the very heart of that idea, that Wilsonian idea, and that was that there's only one nation that a president can work for, and that's that's their nation. And in this case, obviously the United States, and that it doesn't work for an international community. That Roosevelt believed that you know the American president had to work for the American people, and that he was the steward of the American people, and that before you could be a citizen of the world, you had to be a good citizen of your nation. Um, so it that's a really interesting angle that there's a lot more depth and and there's actually not enough scholarship on, which is about Theodore Roosevelt's idea of a league of democracies where like-minded nations work together, rather than what we what we wound up with, which was the League of Nations, where every nation was considered equal regardless of you know their form of government, which I think today is actually really interesting because we have the Security Council in the United Nations today, and and it was created with five powers that were were more important. And so they were l you know not equal nations, right? There's five nations, China, uh USSR, nowadays Russia, UK, France, and the United States, that have a veto power at the at the at the UN. And that's something that Theodore Roosevelt would have approved of because it did make the case that some nations are are certainly more important than others.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'll say uh well one point about Theodore Roosevelt, uh, in terms of how we look at maybe it international organizations nowadays, I do think he would have emphasized again, and he would certainly remind all of us Americans too. He wouldn't just say it to other countries. I do think this element of citizenship, you know, of being a good citizen for your your nation, because I think we've lost that in a lot of ways. I think uh there's been uh understandably there's scholarship about uh international relations, how states operate, whatnot, but but where where does the citizenship element play in? And I think that that should be a big factor when it comes to considering how um how the international world can cooperate on certain issues and whatnot, but but it just can't start with this idea of just nameless states. It really does have to come down to the agency and this and the connection that each world leader has with uh his or her nation. Uh Mike, I'd like to switch to the conservation just uh for for this to wrap up his presidency here. I mean, there's again all all kinds of other elements too. I mentioned consumer protection and you know, big companies and all. Maybe maybe that's something you can tie in as well. But uh what uh what what were some of the the challenges the challenge? You mentioned the the the the thing is they accomplished. What were some of the the challenges that he had to encounter uh domestically and perhaps uh globally in terms of fulfilling that conservation uh policy agenda? You know, what was it more from his own party or was it from business interests or some other groups? Uh what kinds of obstacles did he have to overcome to get to uh what he was able to do?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's both business interests and um and Western interests in particular on environmental conservation. So, you know, and within his own party, there's people like Joe Cannon, who's the powerful speaker of the House, who really wants to throttle some of Roosevelt's plans for environmental conservation, because he just thinks that they are going to damage relations out west in particular. So there's there's a number of um special interests in the West, whether it is uh farmers, ranchers, those that extract wealth from the ground, like uh miners or oil prospectors, any of those groups were really worried that Roosevelt's conservation policies would either reduce their ability to, you know, to profit from whatever industry they're in, or that they would foist so much regulation on them that it would become really uh difficult to get to get their work done. So let me give you an example, right? Like ranchers didn't want to have to fence in their lands, they wanted to just you know allow their their cattle to graze in places and they wanted their cattle to graze in places that Theodore Roosevelt would designate as national forests. But but Roosevelt and his agriculture department and his interior department said that no, you know, that there needs to be regulated use of these lands, that ranchers need to understand that the law of the commons applies to them. If they over-graze an area, then it means that it won't be there for other people, including themselves, to use. So his chief of forestry is really the leader of TR's conservation policy. That's a guy called Gifford Pinchot, who would, in the case of grazing, for example, create a use book. Uh it was a very small, you know, book for foresters to use to explain to ranchers what they should be extracting from the land before they stopped extracting anymore so that it can replenish itself. And you know, the ranchers didn't like that, but actually what wound up happening is that it proved very profitable. I mean, TR was not a he was not a preservationist, he was a conservationist. And the the ranchers, you know, eventually learned that within this system of grazing and sustainable grazing, they were able to turn a profit and you know the natural environment was was able to thrive. Um, and that's that's also the case with the forest system as well. You know, uh lumber companies, timber companies want to extract uh, you know, more and more Roosevelt's protections of the forests mean that they're only allowed a limited take. And what what these companies realize is that actually they're they're doing just fine commercially and they don't have any problems. And actually the land is being cared for, the trees are being cared for in a way that is wholly sustainable for their businesses. So it takes a lot of time for Roosevelt to turn that around. And it's one of the ways that he does it is mainly through publicity. I mean, TR's greatest talent as a president was as a publicist, and uh him and Gifford Pinchot do things like write newsletters, they attend irrigation conferences out west or forestry conferences. In fact, Gifford Pinchot was going to start the United States, the first uh forestry professional society. So this is all wrapped up in this, you know, major charm offensive around their ideas. And eventually it takes time, but you know, in pretty much the duration of their entire uh administration to prove to Western interests that, you know, their their protections and their conservation policies are profitable.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's so much to learn from the Teddy Roosevelt's efforts with conservation, because the environment should be, and and and I guess a few several decades ago, it was a very bipartisan issue. It's so it was something that uh almost everyone could agree to. And there were certain presidents that made some strides on uh on that, on those efforts. But it's it's definitely and maybe some things are changing now, but at least in recent years, it's been hard to have conversations about conservation or about the environment, because it just now with the partisanship and the polarization, when people might think of this issue, they might think, generally speaking, they might think in terms of a left-wing issue. Um I think Sierra Club or or other organizations like that. Uh but in reality, it it there's there's really so much that we there's so much else that we can disagree on in terms of policy, but I do think the environment, and perhaps maybe it's partly because of Theodore Roosevelt's legacy, that I think deep down when you really get people together, you you get away from maybe some online polls and this and that, or just ways that people are primed nowadays with regards to partisanship, that people really do care about the environment. They care about those national forests you were talking about, and they care about having clean water and clean air. And uh, and just so just to reflect again on the you were talking about legacy earlier, uh, I would imagine that if we maybe brought the name Theodore Roosevelt out a bit more, I think people would might people might have a bit more of a positive project because uh they the all people also associate with names too.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm not sure people realize how bad it was uh in that that Gilded Age period where where industry was booming. I mean, maybe they will. There's often a lot of people that there's often a lot of talk about how this era reflects the previous Gilded Age. And are we living through a second Gilded Age? You know, I mean the environmental degradation in America during the first Gilded Age was so bad that you had entire species go extinct, like the passenger pigeon. The passenger pigeon was the most uh there was more passenger pigeons than any other single type of species in the world. There was they think over three billion passenger pigeon pigeons until by 1918, I think, is probably the last time that there's a one in captivity. They're completely wiped out. I mean, how do you wipe out three billion of something? And Theodore Roosevelt, interestingly, was the last person to spot a passenger pigeon in the wild. And uh it was officially confirmed by, you know, him, John Burroughs, and a local farmer. Um, but that was in 1906, I believe. So we're talking about the eradication of a species over the course of maybe 50 or 60 years. I mean, that's that's possible. And that's that's what motivates Roosevelt, is that he's seeing the environment take such a hit. And I think we could be in that position now, too. I mean, you have activists now that are saying exactly the same thing with the warming of the planet, um, with the erosion of coral reefs all over the planet. Um, that that we we are at a tipping point again. I mean, the the the bird situation is just as bad now as it was back in TR's time. There are birds dying. I mean, we're talking about a degradation in the population of birds by 60 to 70 percent since the 1960s. So we're there now.
SPEAKER_01Um imagine talking about recycling back in the the 1880s, 1890s, it'd be like, what? What do you mean? Yeah. Uh but uh I I I think you're I think you're absolutely right, Mike. I think to again to use use some history, use some reflection of the efforts that people did back in those days to get that inspiration. And I think it's a great way to motivate people nowadays. Well, uh Mike, I'd like to uh uh pivot up to your your your areas of research in terms of what you focus on and also maybe just some areas of Theodore Roosevelt that you have an interest in that you that that you think should be studied more by by scholars like you. What what sorts of uh areas of research of Theodore Roosevelt do you focus on the most? And w what do you look forward to the most when you read more about his life and uh what how he contributed to our country?
SPEAKER_00That's a good question. One, because I get to gratuitously self-promote a book that's coming out in May. Um and and two, to say there's not a whole lot that surprises me anymore on TR and his biography, but that around TR are interesting people that we've yet to look at. And so uh let me start by saying that I've got a book coming out called Theodore Roosevelt and the Tennis Cabinet, which is a book about the uh the last day, well, one of the last days in office, he takes a picture with 30 gentlemen around him. And these are the movers and shakers of his administration. They're the ones that come up with the ideas, they're the ones that implement the policies, they're the ones that do the publicity. TR, obviously, he can't do everything. No president, right? So the team that you have around you is vitally important. And this group of people are the ones that make sure that pure food and drug happen. They're obviously the ones that make sure the conservation happens. They're also the ones that support civil rights uh advocacy, which you know, we don't talk a lot about with TR, but there's some important elements of that. They're the ones who reshape the State Department that, you know, create the conditions for the Russo-Japanese War to be ended. And what's interesting is that none of them really know each other. Roosevelt invited these guys to play tennis at the White House. Uh so when the when the when the White House was restored in 1900 or renovated in 1902, uh Roosevelt put a tennis court right next to the president's office. This is before the Oval Office. Taft would create the Oval Office, so TR had a square 15 by 15 of that office was a tennis court, and he invited these guys to play tennis at at three, four o'clock in the afternoon, most days of the week. And he would invite two or three of them at a time. And so most of them didn't know who played tennis with TR. Uh, but there was 35 of them, roughly, that would have come over the the duration of his presidency. And this cut down on things like leaks from the White House. So he would have one person working on immigration, he'd he'd have another two people working on pure food and drug, he'd have another one person working on you know relations with Great Britain or or whatever. And um, and that's how he organized his presidency. He was really a delegator in chief, he was a masterful delegator, and he was also incredibly advisable. He listened to these guys, uh and he took their opinions and and thoughts very seriously, and he did it all while playing tennis. So that's that's a sort of light uh light element of all this. But you know, but it is a serious, it's a serious thing.
SPEAKER_01That's amazing. And then to be able to enjoy the outdoors, you know, uh uh other than August in DC, which I'm I'm sure maybe there was some less tennis uh during those months. But I imagine that just bring people out there, but also to join the fresh air and all, I'm sure that was such such a big relief for him and for for anyone who who had the the privilege of a lifetime to to to play on that uh the amazing tennis court, which of course is still still still is it still there in the original location and all nowadays?
SPEAKER_00No, it's gone. It's gone. So um Roosevelt uh when when Roosevelt left the White House and Taft moved in, the tensions were already there. Taft obviously was not a tennis player and uh he played golf and he had the tennis cabinet removed and they they extended the president's office into what it is now today, the Oval Office. And then later, presidents brought in tennis courts and put them in other parts, but never in the same place that Roosevelt had it. And it was never as central to uh the president and his inner circle. So that was purely uh for just seven years, it was seven short years, it was there, and it was a defining part of TR's administration. And interestingly, in terms of the weather, if it rained, he told people that you can get as much exercise playing water tennis as you can water polo. So, and he had no qualms. And those guys that did not keep up with him, if you couldn't keep up with the tennis, the sets were usually six sets, it could could run three hours. If you couldn't keep up with them on the hikes or the tennis games or the horseback riding or the the name, then you didn't get to be in the inner circle. So you had to have this stamina, this physical brio in order to be close to Roosevelt.
SPEAKER_01Wow. That's that's incredible. Well, I I think that's that's a pretty good test for for for someone like you. I think I think as the president he has every right to to implement that kind of a test there. Well, uh uh Mike, I'd like to turn to a project that is uh it sounds like it's been a long time coming, and I think it's something that is uh is very well deserved for for someone like him, and that is the Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library project that is occurring. And I first read about it maybe a few years ago, but I don't know about you, but I I was surprised that there were I'm surprised that there hasn't been a major institution dedicated to Rosevelt. I mean, it seems like this papers, this influence is kind of in a lot different places. Uh obviously the presidential library system wasn't established until uh until starting. Technically, the FDR wanted the I had the idea of starting with Herbert Hoover uh under NARA. There's some other ones that are run by other organizations or other other maybe other localities. But this is this has got to be quite a big deal for uh not just for Theodore Roosevelt, but for the American public uh nowadays and in the future. So I I have a two-part question for you. One is uh can you tell me about the connection with North Dakota when you talk about the the the presidential library there? Because I think it's fascinating. I think it's based on our talk about conservation, I think it won't be too much of a surprise in that sense. But also, what does Theodore Roosevelt as a whole tell us about the meaning of President's Day, Washington's birthday, and and the significance it has on our civic culture today?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, great. I I'll take both of them in turn. So when Roosevelt dies in 1919, January 6th, only three days later, a memorial group organizes. Actually, there's two that organize within the first week of his death, the men's group and a women's group. And they do um the men's group is congressionally chartered, the first ever congressionally chartered presidential uh fan club, basically. But um, but they they will they will come to dictate his legacy and his the memorials that are dedicated to him. They do actually in two thousand in the early 2000s try to open a presidential library, um, but it's in Long Island, where it was planned to be in Long Island, where Roosevelt lived for most of his life in Oyster Bay. Um, and it's it's just too difficult. I mean, you know, Long Island is a wonderful spot, and spoiling it, I think, with wider roads would have been a problem for locals in Oyster Bay, particularly. Um, so that never really comes together, but the Theodore Roosevelt Association, which is the first memorial association, is incredibly dynamic. I mean, although they don't have a presidential library, the Theodore Roosevelt Collection at Harvard is entirely down to the Theodore Roosevelt Association. I mean, they're responsible for so many things, like the National Memorial on Roosevelt Island in the Potomac, that's that's them. So, uh, and there's many more examples I could give you, but in in the in the once that project failed in Long Island to put a presidential library together, the idea of doing one in North Dakota where there is more space, there's less planning issues, um, and Theodore Roosevelt had a real connection, starts to gain momentum. And then really into the um the early 2020s, that's when um the current CEO at O'Keefe started and I think just galvanized the mission of the organization and was able also to find lots of money from private donors to make it a reality. And they did a search, uh, they did a competition for a design, an architectural design that was won by the architecture firm Snowheda, which is out of New York. And they, you know, they designed this incredible building that honors the conservation legacy, but also provides a space for Theodore Roosevelt's story to be told. And so that's that's what's being built now. It's going to open excitingly in the next four or five months out in Medora, which is in the western, southwestern uh part of the state of North Dakota. It is the area where TR went to sort of salvage his soul, really, after the white the death of his wife and his mother in uh 1884. And um, so he he spends about two years out there off and on, and he does sort of revive himself, and it does, he does eventually, but and he never loses the attraction to the West from that moment on. So he sees himself as a westerner, uh, not only in spirit, but uh in truth as well. I mean, he was a rancher in North Dakota for several years, so uh it is an important place to his legacy, and I think it does honor his his memory in a way that is as meaningful as if it was in Long Island. Um, and I think in terms of President's Day, I mean, you know, we name we name days after President's Day Washington, you know, and President's Day is so important because of Washington's, you know, the I mean, establishing the nation and and all of the precedents that Washington set um as as president is critical to understanding our own our own history. Interestingly enough, Roosevelt's um birthday is celebrated as Navy Day. And I think that's quite fitting because, of course, Roosevelt, you know, set the set the tone for the Navy during his time as assistant secretary and then as president, and of course, the you know, the great white fleet and the circumnavigation of the globe and all that. So I think we honor presidents based on their contributions and Washington's is such an important day because his presidency was just so singularly important for all of the precedents it's set, whether we're talking about you know taxation or or you know the farewell address and our and our place in global affairs, or whether we're talking about the mechanics of the state, um, you know, that that that makes perfect sense to me. Adding Lincoln to the mix on President's Day also makes sense because while Washington established the union, it was Lincoln that saved it. And many of the traditions that we have in our constitutional uh are revived constitution after the Civil War are down to Lincoln. And uh, and you know, those those two moments, the founding of the state and the saving of the state, are just so critically important to where we are today.
SPEAKER_01Indeed, absolutely, yes. And to have Washington, Lincoln, not to mention our in our known nation's capital, to have the Washington Monument and the Lincoln Memorial uh on the same that same plot of land, that same stretch, means it's to this day, it's still an amazing sight to see.
SPEAKER_00Uh I've got a fun fact I've got to share with you, Sherman, about that. I'm I'm glad you mentioned that because Roosevelt's memorial was proposed to be where Jefferson's was in the title basin. So it never happened for political reasons, but it not only was it proposed, John Russell Pope, who was eventually the man who who designed the um the Jefferson Memorial, was the person who designed a Theodore Roosevelt memorial for the title basin. And can you just imagine for a moment if we were here talking about if that if that had happened, we'd be talking about Washington, Lincoln, and Roosevelt and in the sort of sacred spaces of our nation's capital.
SPEAKER_01Wow. I did not know that either. Boy, the uh Mike, you're you're just a treasure trove of trivia here. And this is uh perfect guess for a presidency episode. Uh that that's incredible. Uh now it's obviously with the Dakotas, uh at least uh at least Borklum came around and and got us Mount Rushmore. So uh there's definitely uh and that's probably one of the most prominent uh examples or prominent uh displays of our of some of our great presidents. And so um yes, I I think this is again of just the importance of remembering those who who served in that office, the fact that it's not just about one individual, it's about the the people who hold that, it's about the office. You know, and then I think that's I think Roosevelt really demonstrated that. Well, just to wrap up our last question, Mike, uh just briefly to reflect on Washington's farewell address, uh, of patriotism, faith, national unity, education, physical responsibility, and civility, those those pillars there. Uh what pillar uh of those you think would be most relevant to our conversation today about Teddy Roosevelt and about President's Day generally?
SPEAKER_00I think we've we've touched on all of these in some regard, you know, TR's patriotism. We haven't really talked about his faith, but he certainly was uh a fairly religious. Some people say pan-Christian president. Um national unity was critically important. We briefly talked about citizenship, but I think if we're reflecting here, there's a there's an awful lot more we could say about Roosevelt and citizenship, which is after all about belonging and unity. Um, and you know, the other elements of Washington's farewell address around civility, uh responsibility. We've talked about foreign affairs. Um I think Roosevelt probably tests some of the boundaries of Washington's farewell address, and at least in terms of that idea of entangling in alliances or going out in search of monsters to destroy. I think I've tried to dispel the fact that Roosevelt didn't go out in search of monsters to destroy, but you know, but didn't hesitate to serve America's interests when, you know, when when he felt like he was, you know, entitled to do so. Um, so yeah, I think we've touched on all of that. I mean, Roosevelt felt very strongly about Washington. He felt even more strongly about Lincoln. Um, and you know, but he was a he was a student of that sort of the Whiggish history of uh of American history. He saw Washington as a very as a marble man, as you know, as this sort of the the emblem of the state, the the founder of of many of its institutions and traditions. And so for that reason, you know, felt very strongly about preserving his legacy and following in his footsteps.
SPEAKER_01Well said, Mike. Uh I'll be sure to link uh your other books down in the show notes below for people to check out. Uh but Mike, I just want to say thank you so much for coming onto the podcast. Thank you for all the work that you and your team do and all everybody at Dickinson State and the local area to support such a really important project. I I I I hope to make a visit, and um that's my intention. And uh I I know that this is a project that even although it took a while to finally come to this point to come come to fruition, but uh what an important civic asset and a gift to the American public uh to understand, better understand one of our greatest presidents ever. So, Mike, thank you again so much for coming on the podcast. I really appreciate it.
SPEAKER_00Of course. Thanks, Sherman. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_01Thank you all so much for listening to this episode. I hope you enjoyed it. Make sure to check out the links down in the show notes below. Have a great rest of your day and rest of your week. And remember, a day in America has always been when we are with our friends and fellow citizens.