Friends & Fellow Citizens
In this unique civics podcast, discover how the principles of George Washington's Farewell Address (patriotism, civility, faith, education, national unity, and fiscal responsibility) apply to today! With a focus on American political institutions and policymaking, hear fascinating stories and discussions that any America-loving listener can enjoy!
This non-partisan podcast is a remarkable mix of solo shows, interviews and special guests that gives you a great boost of freedom! New episodes on the first two Mondays of each month!
Friends & Fellow Citizens
#194: William Paca (MD) - An Italian Lawyer Who Questioned "Energetic Government"
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
One of only two Signers of Italian descent, William Paca was a successful lawyer and was heavily involved in the formation of our system of government. What can we learn from his opposition to "energetic government?" Can civic energy come from such a position?
Visit georgewashingtoninstitute.org to sign up for our e-mail list! The site is the one-stop shop of all things Friends & Fellow Citizens and George Washington Institute!
JOIN as a Patreon supporter and receive a FREE Friends & Fellow Citizens mug at the $25 membership level!
IMPORTANT NOTE/DISCLAIMER: All views expressed by the host are presented in his personal capacity and do not officially represent the views of any affiliated organizations. All views presented by guests are solely those of the interviewees themselves and may or may not represent the views of their affiliated organizations, the host, Friends & Fellow Citizens, and/or The George Washington Institute.
Patriotism, faith, national unity, education, physical responsibility, civility, the values that define America. Fascinating stories and talks from America-loving patriots dedicated to preserving freedom, opportunity, and justice. Welcome to the Friends and Fellow Citizens Podcast. Hello, everybody. Welcome to another solo episode of Friends and Fellow Citizens. Welcome to the show. I'm your host, Sherman Tailowski. Thank you all so much for joining me in this episode. If you're new to this podcast, welcome aboard. Thanks for joining us. Firstly, a big, big thank you to our dedicated Patreon supporters. Before we get started to our main content, they are really helping to keep this show going. I just cannot express enough every time. Every time we have a new episode, I always want to just open up with this because uh the show is built on the contributions of others. And uh we we want to make sure we recognize our Patreon members. So for those of you who are Patreon members, please know that we all thank you for your contributions. And if you are interested in supporting this show uh with and would like additional benefits that our Patreon supporters are enjoying, become a Patreon member today. Check our Patreon page down in the show notes below. We're starting to and also have uh some more activity on YouTube, so be sure to check us out on YouTube as well. Also, we have a brand new mug style. I want to make sure I remind myself and all of you of that. We have our footed mug style that is available. We uh are very excited about this new uh and this new type of mug, a new shape mug, and I hope you check it out. It's a great way to contribute to the podcast and a great way to uh keep keep as a souvenir for for your experience, your listenership experience here on Friends and Fellow Citizens. Alright, now let's get to our solo episode. So this is actually going to be, as you can tell with the title, for those of you who have been with this podcast long enough, this is another Sacred Honor Series episode. That is right, we are exploring the signers of the Declaration of Independence and looking at the order in which they likely signed it. I can't, and uh, this is now in the Maryland delegation. Uh don't know we are uh we we did leave one Delaware signer, but for for other re for many reasons, uh he is going to be uh later in the series. But we are continuing our delegation with Maryland, and we covered Samuel Chase, and we're gonna cover one of his best friends, best buddies. So uh this is uh pretty fitting here, and we're we are talking about William Packa or William Paca. I think I'll say Paca for now. Uh, William Paca was born on October 31st, uh, 1740, born on Halloween. I'm pretty sure that's that's not the way he probably remembers that day. Uh probably now go trick-or-treating for uh for a few years, but uh he was uh born in the 1740s and uh was educated in Philadelphia. So even though he's a Maryland signer, uh however he went on to get his education in Pennsylvania, which is of course not that far away. And he uh in courtesy of the Constitution Center, by the way, the National Constitution Center has information about all these signers. So I'm using that as part of a guide for this episode. And they're fantastic. I've actually met the uh the director of the Constitution Center. So uh this is a great resource if you want to learn more about just everything about the Constitution or all things civics in the late 1700s. Packa is uh interestingly one of two uh American signers of Italian descent uh in the in this era, which I find very interesting. I'm sure that he probably fit in as well in well in Maryland as well in the north end of Boston, uh, which is I I don't I don't I'm sure he got along with the Massachusetts signers and all. Maybe they talked about good Italian food. I don't know what and the point is uh he he is that's pretty unique for him and uh and certainly significant for that. The uh the other signer, I believe, is Cesar Rodney, who has some Italian descent. In any case, um Pacca uh was uh very much into law, so that's what he did. He went to study law, uh admitted to the bar, and set up his own practice in Annapolis. Uh and uh Pacca uh was not one, I mean he got a good education, decent education. You would imagine that he had a pretty good upbringing, but it was actually because he married into an elite political class. Uh one of his uh was his in-laws, uh uh really uh his would be his wife's stepfather. His name was Daniel Delaney, and he was actually one of the most uh prominent political figures uh at the time. Now, not someone whom we need to cover here, but just the fact that he knew people, uh knew a lot of people in politics. So, again, there's kind of a difference between, say, uh John Adams, who was very politically connected and very famous, and versus someone like Daniel Delaney, who uh for maybe for wealth and for other reasons was politically connected and maybe not a prominent individual. And so Packa was able to uh get into politics there and uh just and uh come along the lines of the other signers, start uh PACA started to become very vocal about the about the the British government and uh and see seeing these tensions going around. He did his part to write and to express his views uh about the Stamp Act. And the Stamp Act is the uh first major uh taxation that the colonies start to really rally against. And then now it wasn't the only one, but it was he it was certainly a big enough impetus for him to start a chapter of the Sons of Liberty. Now, I I don't know how active he was as one of the members of the Sons of Liberty. Just remember that the Sons of Liberty were the among the most active and I would argue the most militant of the activist groups at the time. I will say the Sons of Liberty I would imagine drew some controversy because you did have some founders that did not approve of the way the Sons of Liberty did things. One of them, one of the examples being the Boston Tea Party. There were some individuals who were not very confident in not only the tactics, but I guess because of the effectiveness. So it's not to say that the Sons of Liberty were not important or that they everything that they were doing was was problematic. It's just that well, like with any activist group, there it's going to divide people within that movement. And certainly uh starting a chapter of the Sons of Liberty reper demonstrates, at least for a signer, that that signer was very, very passionate about uh these uh these issues about being a patriot. And uh certainly then the Sons of Liberty should get a lot of credit for the way they rally people because it's not enough to just read fancy letters and all that because the average person there, because of the fact that not everybody can attain a um uh higher education track, shall we say, and it was important for for people to be engaged. It's not just influencing George Washington or Jefferson or William Packa, it's also about uh the grassroots and how you engage with the people to get people to come on your side, because that was also a very important component when it came to who supported the patriot cause and who supported the loyalist cause. Packa gained quite a good reputation, and according to the Constitution Center, says here that uh John Adams described Packa as acting generously and nobly during the debates. I I don't know how much space you really have to be generous and noble during these debates. I I just say that because the debates were very raucous, from my understanding. It's not a a simple civil debate all the time. Certainly there were those times, but remember, these people were very passionate about the these issues, and people really disagree on independence. So for if if if we're taking John Adams' word here, uh describing Paca as someone who is generous and noble, that's a very good quality there. Uh Benjamin Rush also talks about Packa saying, quote, he was beloved and respected by all who knew him, unquote. Very, very uh very well put, I'm I imagine, Benjamin Rush. Maryland, of course, uh was uh again one of the uh smaller delegations, so the the certainly the impact of any one of those signers could have made a a decision uh or could have swayed the state one way or another. But PACA was uh quite on board with independence, and he voted in favor of it. And so that is that is part of uh this series, of course. In terms of the signers, and so he is the next signer we are we are have officially covered here on the sacred honor series. Uh when PACA was uh was in the Maryland Senate, this was around the time of the Revolutionary War, he later on he served as a judge, and he actually was appointed by George Washington, uh by President of Washington, I should say, in 1790, and he landed a position on the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland. Now, I I just want to say this is very key because I'm gonna backtrack it a bit in just a second and talk about some of the well one one of the things he he argued against, which I think is also worth discussing. PACA was one to accept this job knowing that, and with everybody knowing that this was an experiment and that not everybody was satisfied with the final product, even as the Constitution and the Bill of Rights were passed, people still had skepticism. And from that skepticism of government, you know, you're going to get people who are not gonna be happy for a range of reasons, and that's probably one of the reasons why in American history we've always had this tradition of skepticism of government for better or for worse. And I imagine that the founding and our understanding, the the all the attempts we make to connect with the founding of the country, I think drives this interest in skepticism. Again, some lot number a lot of that skepticism is beneficial because we always have to be skeptical of government. We can't let just like government just do whatever it wants and not pay attention to what it does. But it can also not be very effective, too, because uh when when it gets in the way of governance, when it gets in the way of the fact that when we have elections, it does give the majority some element to govern. Now, they they can face opposition, but generally the when uh majorities win elections, they they have that latitude to be able to govern and to pass uh a number of different policies. Now, if they pass policies that we don't like, obviously they'll face consequences. But just so you know, that this idea of PACA joining the federal government as uh as a judge might not seem a big deal, and he's it's not like he was on the Supreme Court, even though the Supreme Court wasn't really a big deal until John Marshall came along. But just the fact that he decided to serve even as he had his own reservations and his own views that might not have aligned with maybe some in the Washington administration, that I think represents some element of service. I think it's it's worthy of giving someone the credit for for that. Now, I mentioned I was going to backtrack a bit because uh PACA was an anti-federalist. So he was not very happy with the Constitution, and it was because of people like PACA that um rallied together and got the Continental Congress, or I should say the Constitutional Convention, to uh to come together again to adopt the Bill of Rights. Packa was very skeptical of something here, and I I had never heard of this term, but I think it makes sense. So let's just follow me here for a second on uh on this term. Uh something that's meant that was mentioned in by the Constitution Center is that PACA was not in favor of something called end quote energetic government for the United States. Energetic government. Why don't you all think about that for a second? What does it mean for a government to be energetic? It might mean a lot of things. We think of energetic, or you think active, you might be thinking, okay, this this government is constantly working every day, 24-7, 365, uh working on what is uh well, working on the big issues. That's probably the the the the surface level that we hear. The thing is that every government's gonna say that. So so it doesn't really add a lot of value as to what it means to be energetic government. So uh I thought I would take a look um just put energetic government into uh into Google. And uh one of the documents I came up with is the uh Federalist Papers, and particularly Federalist number 23. I know Alexander Hamilton would not mind me giving him air time on about the signers, but uh, I do I do think it's important to talk a little bit about Federalist 23 and what and maybe wonder why Packa was against this. Remember, the Federalist papers were written by Federalists, so it's not surprising that Packa would be against some of the views of of Hamilton and Madison and John Jay. However, it's also valuable to see okay, well, what why is it that he was opposed to this term? And that's that's a question that you might have to answer, that we all might have different answers to. So let's let's talk about Federalist number 23, and what and it leads to this energetic government. And the Federalist number 23 basically covers this idea of the ability for the federal government to raise armies. And in this paper, uh in this letter, the big takeaway you have to have is it is much, much um it's uh it's much more much more strongly aligned with Nash the national government federalist ideology than what was presented in the Constitution. Um for in the the big thing for uh Hamilton, because Hamilton's the one who wrote uh number twenty-three, is that the uh Publius, effectively the quote unquote author of this uh of this paper, basically says that the uh the federal government should not face in any sort of resistance on uh creating armies. And the fact that the the common defense uh argument is that because the a com because we have common threats, because we have national security threats, the federal government should not be able to uh be uh be facing obstacles, including um any restrictions, including restrictions on the power of taxation. And so this is a very, very big case, very, very federalist of Hamilton to write something like this. Remember, the Federalist papers are written to uh advocate for the Constitution. And what I find interesting is the fact that the the that this letter goes beyond what the Constitution actually says or what it states. Something that uh what is is critical here is you know Hamilton is uh is discussing, of course, the uh the the the fact that the Articles of Confederation didn't work. And I think he's absolutely right. There I don't think there's a dispute, particularly among the anti-Federalists, uh, that the Articles of Confederation were far too weak, that it did not give the colonies and or future states some element of coming together. It's a bit like a collective action problem where people know that the best way to get things done to work together, but for a variety of reasons, there are incentives, there are built-in incentives that prevent people from actually working together. And so part of it is a collective action problem, part of it, I think, is also the uh the weak system and the fact that you need to have a system of government that a stronger national government that can articulate the national priorities so that when there are threats, that the whole country can respond. And so Hamilton doesn't stray away from that at all. He obviously emphasizes these points. But uh well, let's go to basically the final part because I think this is really a wrap-up here. I'll make sure to link fellows number 23 down to show what's below if you'd like to read more or like to read the text. But here's here's how he ends it. And he does mention energy, energetic a couple other times earlier, but this is the last part where he's arguing for the for his position here. I trust, however, that the impracticability of one general system cannot be shown. I am greatly mistaken, if anything of weight has yet been advanced of this tendency, and I flatter myself that the observations which have been made in the course of these papers have sufficed to place the reverse of that position in as clear a light as any matter still in the womb of time and experience can be susceptible of. This at all events must be evident that the very difficulty itself drawn from the extent of the country is the strongest argument in favor of an energetic government. For any other can certainly never preserve the union of so large an empire. If we embrace the tenets of those who oppose the adoption of the proposed constitution as the standard of our political creed, we cannot fail to verify the gloomy doctrines which predict the impracticability of a national system pervading the entire limits of the present Confederacy. I think of this as interesting because when he says you're in favor of an energetic government I'm curious to think an energetic government do we mean energetic government when we think about it today in 2026 or any other year after the 1790s? What does it mean to have an energetic government? Is an energetic government always a good thing? Which is subjective, I know, but uh what what is the effectiveness, I should say? What is the effectiveness of an energetic government? Is it the worst thing ever if a government is not energetic? And so uh the these questions are gonna be important. I think for for anyone who's in office or thinking of or of participating in politics, what what does it mean to bring energy into it? There's the energy of social media activism. Maybe that's a form of energy. Maybe it's the policy walks, the people who are always grinding out new policies on foreign affairs or on health care or education or national security. There's that kind of energy. Um there could be the energy that Hamilton is talking about, which is this idea that the federal government should not be impeded in its efforts to create armies. That to according to the Federalists, that r that sort of strong national government, that is the energy. And so I I think looking back at this term energetic government and back to how PACA might see it, I think PACA might see this argument of common defense as perhaps too much of a justification for expansion of government. Um PACA was an anti federalist, so therefore uh is going to be favoring more on state government. And there's there's multiple sides here, right? But but I think this this really very much leads to a couple of takeaways that I'd like to leave you all here. The first is that understand that the the founders have Had some really interesting inconsistencies where their arguments. And part of it is because when we understand this is just my view here, but the the the way I've understood the way the manner in which we learn about the founders is it can kind of run on this spectrum of pure romanticization. So people would just say, oh, the founders are perfect and all that. They set up everything. We have to do everything that they they they said they were going to do. And then the other side, which is, you know, you can't can't can't trust whatever they say, or they they had all these flaws with slavery and this and that. And neither of these ends can be accepted, in my view. You cannot have uh this uh what I th what I found is a very contemporary movement, uh found unsurprisingly on the fringes of the political spectrum here. I think what needs to needs to occur is is first of all, and then the understanding that the founders are still experimenting. And it's not just the founders, we're also experimenting. When the founders call an experiment, I don't think they're just saying that as a way of excusing themselves and just say, well, what what we're what we do, well, if it doesn't work, well, I guess too bad. I mean, obviously you want you want a country to succeed, and just like the founders from sure wanted the country to succeed for their posterity and for for other people's posterity. But the reason why I think it's an experiment is because we're we're always learning something new about history. We're always learning something new about our own politics. There's never going to be one person or one group in this country that has a dominant view that, well, we've got it all figured out. We've we might have figured out a lot of things between 1776 and 2026, but we haven't figured out what it's like to be a country that's at least 250 years old. There's always a a learning process here. Um, but also that the the founders clearly were engaging in politics. And guess what? In politics, there's always discrepancies and differences on what is it that you put out maybe as a policy or what you put out in the media versus what you do behind the scenes. And so here, remember that the found the Federalist Papers was was an advocacy element, and so this is not a like let's bring both sides together, let's bring the anti-federalists and the federalists together. No, that that was not the how the Federalist Papers were operating. Now, we cite them a lot because they bring a lot of political information and a lot of political theory, what the founders were thinking. But this is this at the end of the day, it this was still politics. The Constitution was about politics, and it's and it's it is helpful to know both sides, but at that time, you know, people did need to take sides, they did need to take positions on why they disagreed with Alexander Hamilton, and people did disagree with Alexander Hamilton, and and by by a lot, like I mean, very, very disagree. Just ask Aaron Burr. Um, well, actually, I'm sure I'm sure a lot of people asked Aaron Burr what he thought of Alexander Hamilton, and well, we we we don't need into that now on what what happened in Weehawk, New Jersey, 1807, 1809. I I want to I want to bring this back here about the really talking about the arguments that are discussed with and how PACA might have seen things. I I do want to preface that uh this is a lot on speculation of what how PACA and other anti-federists might be thinking about the common defense. And I think one of the first things they would think about is that leading to this takeaway, is that state government needs to play active roles alongside the federal government on these issues. Um I don't think that a lot of these big issues, national issues, we don't often think why are they national? It's not just the fact that it's the federal government and therefore it's an issue that affects everybody, affects the entire nation as a whole. But what what are the dynamics of why issues remain a federal issue? For example, when we talk about education, uh we we hear a lot about the Department of Education, but we we we just can't seem to get around the fact that the the Department of Education, which whatever your views on it, uh education policy is done at the state and local level. And so if someone were to come around and say, Well, I don't like the education system in America, it's like, well, well, I I I think I think you can possibly make an argument about higher education, because that then there's certainly a lot of federal federal laws and regulations related to that. But you can't have a blanket conversation about education in America when that person lives in a local jurisdiction, it lives in a state. And so the real question is, well, are you just not satisfied with the education in your state? And so the conversation just about these issues really needs to be important here. Uh when talk about state versus federal government. But in terms of common defense, I I'm curious, and and this is this will be something for you all to think about. Common defense when we think about military and what I think those definitely need to be uh in the in the federal government. However, as a as something to think about, what it what does common defense mean when it comes to say cyber? Because cybersecure cyber attacks don't know these differences between or can't detect the differences between the national interests and the state interests. And so if there's a cyber attack on, let's say, the electricity grid in Nebraska, for example, not to pick on Nebraska, just as an example, what what does it mean in terms of national security? Is there a conversation about our infrastructure across the country? Is there more conversation about the infrastructure in California, maybe perhaps? I I don't I I don't want to provide all the uh every single possibility or every single answer here, but what I want you all to think about is when it comes to these issues like common defense and how kind of fluctuates between state and federal, i is there a role for state government to at least be a part of these federal government efforts for common defense? I think one of the things I often hear is there's the people who say, well, the federal government's not doing enough. There's this argument that the federal government needs to take on more. That might be the case, but what if the other question is the federal government maybe needs to be maybe not doing enough on laying out leadership or laying out a vision for other states? Now every state wants to do things in its own way. That's understandable, and that and that's a big part of politics. However, if the federal government really cared about an issue, let's say immigration, let's say on national security or on cyber, wouldn't there be a push for the federal government to be active to say here here are ways that we can have very strong cyber policy or uh or ways in which uh maybe states can uh access certain grants, but maybe contingent on uh on improving these these elements here. So I'm just trying to suggest some uh ideas that again going back to the early days, early days of our country, we've always had this debate on the powers of the federal government. But as we saw with Federalist number 23, that debate is not only still going, but that there were founders who, again, very much disagree with one another and who give us some window as to how we can think about what it means to have an energetic government. Does an energetic government have to be big government? Or can a government be smaller but still be energetic? Can you have an energetic government uh involved in foreign affairs, but also still be energetic on the domestic front? And so these kinds of things, I want you all to think what what does energetic government mean to you? Is uh what does it mean for it to be effective? I think a good example I'll give you is in Nevada. We have the Office uh of uh economic development, we actually call it GOAG, Governor's Office of Economic Development. And it's obvious that it sounds like well, it's it's about companies and other business interests looking at uh doing business in Nevada. I know somebody who works there, I obviously won't name the person, but one of the things I've I've heard from him is that you have companies that are coming in and the particularly foreign companies, uh certain foreign companies, not all, but certain foreign companies that we compete against, like China, like Russia, like others, maybe even uh uh maybe even uh Iranian. I there's there's companies that are coming from these adversarial countries here, uh adversarial to the United States, uh, that are saying, well, we want to invest uh in some sort of project, and it makes zero sense, makes zero business sense. It kind of makes you wonder the state, literally the state of Nevada, and I can imagine the st Iowa, Michigan, Tennessee, Florida, you name all the other states. I'm sure every single state is figuring out what is this frontier of security now. Because common defense, maybe back in the days, meant just meant m or predominantly meant armies or military, and that still should be in the powers of the federal government. But what are the additional layers of these issues of common defense that we might have to consider on the state level? So just some food for thought. I'll wrap it up here with just a little bit about a little bit more about William Packa. Uh Packa was served, and as I mentioned, um as the as uh on the U.S. District Court in District of Maryland, uh confirmed obviously by the Senate. This is of course is just um a very recent process. Uh and so he served on the federal bench. I read here that he his opinion was the first district court opinion to be published, which uh I think is very interesting. Now it was reversed, however, that's gotta be a pretty big deal for for someone like him who cared a lot about the law. Uh Packa was able to serve until his death on October 13th, 1799. Same year, actually, that uh George Washington passed away as well. The story of a signer like William Packa shows that the dynamics of the founders, their views on what government is, what it should be, and how much energy it has are interesting debates that we can reflect on here in the present day. Thank you all so much for listening to this episode. I hope you enjoyed it. Make sure to check out the links down in the show notes below. Have a great rest of your day and rest of your week. And remember, a day in America has always been. We are with our friends and fellas.